Jewish Architecture: An Interview with Daniel Libeskind |
|
| Libeskind talks to Zeek about the new Jewish Museum in San Francisco, working in an interfaith environment, and post-diasporic Judaism | |
by Jo Ellen Green Kaiser, May 15, 2008 |
|
Wowed by the example
of Frank Gehry's Bilbao Guggenheim, museums around the world have raced to
commission brilliant, experimental architects to build structures at least as
noteworthy as their collections. Architect Daniel Libeskind has become the star
of the Jewish museum world with his stunning designs for the Jewish Museum
Berlin, Danish Jewish Museum, and now the San Francisco Contemporary Jewish
Museum.
Unique in being a museum without a permanent collection, the San Francisco Contemporary Jewish Museum has, for over twenty years, devoted itself to exhibitions that explore contemporary perspectives on Jewish culture. Libeskind's new building, opening June 8, 2008, will allow the museum to remain flexible in defining Jewish identity by offering a variety of differently shaped and purposed spaces, including ones specially designed for music, film, and hands-on art education, as well as the more typical white-wall galleries.
Daniel Libeskind has become best-known for winning the World Trade Center design competition (and the resultant brouhaha). Yet his most important work may well be found elsewhere, ranging from the severe angles and sharp edges of the Royal Ontario Museum to the graceful, curving, almost bowed forms of his Reflections project in Singapore to the San Francisco museum with its almost aggressive blue beacon jutting out from the shell of an old water pumping station.
Zeek talked with Libeskind about creating a specifically Jewish space for the San Francisco museum in the conversation that follows.
ZEEK: I've had an opportunity to tour the Jewish Museum of San Francisco and I was very impressed-the spaces are complex visually and yet open and inviting. I understand they are deeply symbolic, with a physical "chet" and "yud"-the word Chai-- defining the space. Can you talk about the design for our readers?
Libeskind: I conceived the project as a new Jewish institution that is looking forward and celebrates life. And what better emblem and symbol of Jewish culture and identity than life itself? That is what Judaism is all about. So I created a museum which is almost an illuminated manuscript in three dimensions, which in its margins interacts with others' history, the history of the power station [which was already on the site and is incorporated into the design], the history of Yerba Buena Gardens [the site], the history of the Bay Area. The building in itself is a conversation with different levels of history.
ZEEK: I noticed that this museum differs from the Jewish Museum in Berlin or the Danish Jewish museum, both of which you also designed, in that those museums look backwards while this one looks forward. In fact, it
![]() |
|---|
Jewish Museum Berlin
|
only looks forward, since it doesn't have any permanent exhibits. I was interested in your understanding of a Jewish identity that is not connected to a Jewish past, and what the challenge was for you?
Libeskind: This project was very different from my Jewish projects in Europe, because those always have the memory of the destruction of European Jews--that is part of the dark history of Europe. That is certainly not the case in San Francisco and America. So this building is a celebration of America, American Jews, American openness, and the vitality of the Jewish community in America. In that sense, you are right, it is a museum that really looks forward. But I would say it is still based on emblems and symbols that are rooted deeply in the Jewish tradition. The inextinguishable light of the building itself, and the meaning of those Hebrew letters, is not just symbolic or metaphorical--you cannot disassociate the symbols from the meanings they contain, which is quintessentially Jewish as well.
ZEEK: As you are talking, it seems that one of the challenges was the challenge of working in an interfaith environment without assimilating.
Libeskind: Absolutely. The building had to grow out of a turn of the nineteenth century building, a power station, and also the bottom of a twentieth century hotel [the Jewish museum shares a basement and carves a first floor room space from the Four Seasons hotel next door]. Then the building needs to find an identity that is not compromised, not blending in, but cutting across these existing structures and establishing an identity that is not ambiguous.
ZEEK: A lot of people have suggested that Jewish identity is undergoing a fundamental transformation post-Holocaust and post-State of Israel; some people say that Judaism itself is post-diasporic and we need to have a new idea of what it means to be a Jew. I was wondering if you had been engaged in these ideas and how you see Jews and Judaism in the 21st century?
Libeskind: That's a great question. I can only answer for myself. For many complex reasons the Jewish world has become very polarized. We have on one hand a growth of religion, a growth of the religious movements, and on the other hand we have the increasing assimilation of Jews. For me, the 21st century is about bringing back to the center a Jewish identity, an identity that is free, that is open, that is complex.
ZEEK: So what you are doing with this museum is creating spaces that have a kind of ambiguity to them-they can become anything. I am thinking particularly of the auditorium space. There is flexibility built in.
Libeskind: Absolutely, flexibility and fluidity. At the same time, each of the spaces is not just iconic superficially, by its shape, but because they are rooted in other dramas of Jewish history--the drama of contemporary Israel, the drama of what the synagogue means, the drama of Talmud and its commentaries. It's a break in space.
It's certainly true that for so long, it was a cliche that Jews were not a visual people. That Jews were forbidden to engage in spacial affect. But that's certainly not true. If you go to the biblical text, we know there are the cherubim in the Temple, we know there was a rich visual world. It was not the world of pagan idolatry, but it communicated to people.
ZEEK: Yes, there's a huge section of Torah devoted to describing spaces.
Libeskind: And very rich spaces. Jews are so implicated in architecture. Such great chapters are devoted to the tabernacle and the Temple and the ark and the eruv, because space and what it means is so importantly embedded in Jewish memory. In a sense this is a presentation in contemporary terms of a very historical topic.
ZEEK: I had a question about the beautiful blue tiles you used on the new parts of the facade. They made me think of water. When I think of a Jewish element, I usually think of fire.
Libeskind: Fire, but you also have to think of revelation, which is blue. It's not a coincidence that tallit are white and blue, that the State of Israel's flag is white and blue. The blue is not just a naturalistic idea of the blue that comes from the tallit and from water. It comes from the idea of eternity, of coming out of blue into reality.
ZEEK: As you talk, you talk about the fluidity and transitory nature of the space, and you also talk about eternity and the things that remain unchanging, and that tension seems very essential to an ancient religion like Judaism.
![]() |
|---|
The Danish Jewish Museum
|
Libeskind: That's a good way of putting it. I think the reason Judaism is open is because it is based on something eternal. Because freedom is built so deeply into the Jewish tradition, everything is new, everything is possible.
ZEEK: As a writer, that's why I love the way our text is written over so many times, it's very freeing. You have layers of text, which means you can keep writing on them.
Libeskind: Exactly. People coming to this museum will inscribe themselves into the text of the museum. By moving through the spaces of L'Chaim, each person will inscribe themselves in a unique way, through a text that is endless. That is part of the notion of the building. It is not just a plan, but a permanent encounter which depends on the participants to make it live.
ZEEK: Thank you.
Hump Day Art: Psychedelic Hebrew |
|
by Maya Wainhaus, April 24, 2008 |
|
It's not officially Hump Day anymore, but with all the Passover goings-on it can be easy to lose track of time. It may be a day late, but here's your weekly serving of Hump Day Art.
In JAMS2 (Jewish Animated Mandala Series), artist Melissa Shiff used Judaica from the Jewish Museum in her kaleidescope-like video for the Off the Wall exhibit. This is not the first time Shiff has played off of Jewish iconography; she's reinvented the Jewish wedding, and decked out entire rooms in matzo.
At the end of Off the Wall, Shiff displayed a series of video projections featuring swirling, colorful Hebrew letters that served as the backdrop for a fashion show and performance. The work is both gorgeous and surprising, as she finds the geometry and patterns in the letters. Here are some stills from the projections at the museum.
Last week: Modern Day Exodus
Hump Day Art: The American Dream Via Russia |
|
by Maya Wainhaus, April 9, 2008 |
|
Alina and Jeff Bliumis are a duo of artists from the former Soviet Union who use photography to document the often ambiguous notion of the American dream. Their 'Casual Conversations' series is an ongoing project that “explores migration, displacement, and assimilation through dialogue and interactions with strangers.”
Here are some of the photographs from their recent residency at the Jewish Museum in New York.
Related: Off the Wall at the Jewish Museum
Chassidic Fashion Designer Levi Okunov
Mixing Heresy and High Fashion, Levi Okunov Dresses Women up as Torahs
Last Week: More to the Lower East Side Than Hipsters
Hump Day Art: Chassidic Fashion Designer Levi Okunov |
|
by Maya Wainhaus, March 27, 2008 |
|
Two weeks ago we showed you photos of the Jewish Museum's Off the Wall exhibit under construction. Now that the exhibit is in full swing, take a look at the results. These photos feature fashions from Chassidic designer Levi Okunov. For more on Okunov, check out the interview below, in which the designer talks about his inspirations, Chassidic teachings, spirituality, and the Jewish Museum.
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Levi Okunov discusses his residency at the Jewish Museum from mobius1ski on Vimeo.
Last week: Bagels with a Side of Art
Win Tickets to Exclusive Parties and Readings! |
|
by Jewcy Staff, March 18, 2008 |
|
Jewcy is giving away tickets to three upcoming events! To enter to win, follow these steps to get on our exclusive guest list.
1. Register and fill out your Jewcy Profile.
2. Click on an event below and send the personal message, "I want tix!"
3. We'll send you back a message to confirm your acceptance.
Off the Wall Parties at the Jewish Museum
Thursdays March 20 and 27
A two-week open studio project featuring eleven artists creating and performing in the museum. In this live laboratory, different groups of artists will develop a work-in-progress each week.
Send a personal message for tickets!
Forward: Readings by Arnon Grunberg and Victorial Redel
Friday March 21
Join Emmy Award-winning author and architect James Sanders for an introduction to Jewish New York past, and celebrate two authors looking forward with the launch of The Jewish Messiah and The Border of Truth. Live klezmer band, flowing cocktails, and dancing against the lights of Lower Manhattan.
Send a personal message for tickets!
Hump Day Art: Off the Wall at the Jewish Museum |
|
by Maya Wainhaus, March 12, 2008 |
|
Starting this Sunday, the Jewish Museum in New York is hosting a fantastic new exhibit called Off the Wall: Artists at Work. The exhibit features 11 artists who will be taking over the gallery spaces at the museum with projects in music, fashion, and performance and visual arts. To help gear up for Off the Wall, check out these photos of the galleries being set up for the show. Over the the next few weeks, Jewcy will be covering Off the Wall, so stay tuned for more about artists and events.
We're also giving away tickets to the Off the Wall parties on March 20 and 27. To enter to win, send a private message saying "I want to party" to the Jewcy user Jewish Museum Off the Wall (you have to create a profile to do this). See you there!

Last Week: Wild Beasts Carved and Gilded With Love
| Superman's Jewish Roots | |
|
by Maya Wainhaus, January 4, 2008
|
|
It's been 70 years since the Man of Steel first sprang forth from the imaginations of Jewish writers Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster. Now the Jewish Museum of Florida has a new exhibit on display called Zap! Pow! Bam! The Superhero: The Golden Age of Comic Books 1938-1950 about the fascinating, and Jewcy, history of the comic book industry. If you're not headed to Miami any time soon, take a look at the Miami Herald's informative review of the exhibit, as well as a slide show of some featured comic book covers.
| Hyper Jewish Museum | |
|
by Batya, August 7, 2007
|
|
The only "tourist" thing I do when in New York is go to museums.
On previous visits, besides a traditional evening with a cousin in the Jewish Museum on Fifth Avenue, the museums I see are MOMA, Natural History and similar classics. This visit I finally admitted that I've never liked the dinosaur skeletons, and the art ones can be boring.
View from the museum. So I decided to take my daughter's advice and go to a new museum, one I hadn't even heard of, the Museum of Jewish Heritage. A friend and I took the subway downtown to check it out. First stop was the restaurants, because even grandmothers have to eat. Food was great, and the free samples of the soups were appreciated.
We got a kick out of "remembering" things considered "history."
It was almost perfect, until we entered an exhibit with so many "speakers" going on at once, I thought I was in a nursery class for hyperactive kids allergic to all medications. It was too close and crowded, with horrendous acoustics.
I had to flee and didn't get to see everything. I had heard enough!