Religion & Beliefs

Something To Think About Next Time You Feel Like A Complete Twit For Asking

By AmyGuth / August 22, 2007

This week's haftorah is one of seven "Haftarot of Consolation", starting on Tisha B'Av and going until Rosh HaShanah. Yes. Right. I've thinking about consolation a little lately, because let's face it, life happens (as I'm fond of saying) and presents moments for us to consider pretty often, if not, you know, constantly. So, bear with me as I stretch this a little for a sec. We all have good days and bad days, invincible days and shaky ones. I think most of us prefer to at least try to solve our minor, day-to-day issues on our own, and most of the time, we do. But, life happens. Sometimes, circumstances overwhelm us, too much crap piles on at once from too many directions, buttons get pushed, and we find the wind knocked squarely out of whatever coping skills we've come to rely on. And, if you're like most of us, friends, family and other loved ones pop up at such times to offer support. It goes without saying that it's very reasonable to expect our loved ones, in such moments of overwhelm, to hug us instead of standing still and doing nothing. We trust them to listen when we need to blow off some steam and reassure us when we feel fragile. Of course. That's part of the deal. We don't keep fair-weather friends around; we keep people that sick with us through good and bad, just as we do the same for them. Right. It's easy, and usually accurate, to call un-supportive people fair-weather friends. But, it might be worth considering that we can be just as guilty, in a sense.

Sometimes it's really difficult to ask for the support you need, especially when you're already feeling thin-skinned and wobbly from all the stress you're under. And, a lot of times, it seems like a lot of conflict arises from this very point. There's a balance to strive for, I think, of reasonable expectation of support to come from our loved ones without having to ask– hugs, a sympathetic ear, etc.– and the responsibility we have to ourselves and each other to ask for support and help when we need it. How many times have you been stressed-out or pissed off or whatever and felt dismissed by a friend? Sure, it's happened to all of us. It happened to me not long ago. I was stressing and fretting and feeling the weight of the world and when I complained, looking for a little support, I felt blown off. And, feeling blown-off, in the moment, made me feel pretty angry. Angry, that is, until I reminded myself I hadn't communicated that I needed anything but to vent. I'd gone looking for support but hadn't asked for it. And well, as far as I'm aware, nobody in my inner-circle is a mind-reader. (Uh, and if any of you are mind-readers, eesh, have I got some explaining to do.)

So, what about asking for help and support? It's brutal sometimes isn't it? Sometimes, asking for help makes me feel like the limits of my proficiencies (and far-from-proficiencies) are pointed out in bright blinking neon aarows for the entire world to see. (And, hello, how uncomfortable is that?) Sometimes it feels easier to just keep stressing and fretting than to ask for help. And, on some occasions, it's hard to accept help when it's offered. We don't want to be a pain in the ass to someone we love, we don't want them to be stressed out like we are right then, right? We maybe deep down fear that asking too much of the people we care for will make them resent us, or, be angry at us, or worst of all, want to avoid us when we need them in the future. But, maybe, the opposite is true? Maybe (not to be all Schmaltzarella on you) asking for help and accepting it when it is offered, in a way, actually helps us better connect? Think about it, for reals. Okay, we feel good when we help people, right? Mitzvot, giving tzedekah, moat chitim, bikkur cholim, all of those kinds of things leave us feeling, kvell-y, uplifted and good, like we've done well and helped push a little tikkun olam into the world someplace. And, on a more micro level, when we do a favor for a friend or family member, we feel good when they express appreciation, even in small ways. Right? Right. So, how whacked out is that this idea comes so easily to us, yet we find it so hard to accept help when it comes our way? And, if you think about it a step further, in doing so, aren't we denying the people who care for us the same opportunity to feel good about lending a hand where it is needed? Sure, we're taking the support being offered us, but in doing that, we're giving to the people we love, in a sense. I mean, doesn't a true mitzvah have to have both parts of the equation (giving/receiving) in harmony for it to be really a mitzvah at all? Sure it does. Also, what about the merit in giving someone the opportunity to do good in the world? Doesn't that count for something? Sure, it does, too. And, if we look at it that way, half the mitzvah is in the asking. Half the mitzvah is up to us.

POST A COMMENT

  • By AmyGuth 8/23/07 at 2:24 a.m. UTC

    Yeah, ZBird, I know those kind of people, too. It's draining and unbalanced to be around them. I hear you. Oy, do I ever. :)

    Thanks, Tamar. I agree– I also find it easier to deal with an attention-seeker for what s/he is than a friend I don't know how to best support.

    http://guthagogo.com

     

  • Tamar Fox
    By Tamar Fox 8/22/07 at 11:08 p.m. UTC

    Z, I think you're right that there are too many people who are too quick to ask for support from friends and family.  It can be really frustrating, but because I know what's going on in those situations–Oh, Sally just needs some attention again–I find them less frustrating than when I see a friend who's suffering in some way, and I have no idea how to help her.  That's why I think Amy's point is so important.  We all need help sometimes, and asking for help, asking for *specifically* what we need is  hard to do, but so important, both for us and for our friends who care about us.

    Amy, you're a rock star!

  • By zbird 8/22/07 at 7:01 p.m. UTC

    Lending consolation and not being afraid to ask for support when you need it is all well and good.  And I definitely know people (including myself, I'm sure) who can be better at both.

    On the other hand, I think we all also know emotional black holes, who seem to have never-ending sorrows that always cry out for our attention, sucking away energy that can be better used for more deserving causes. People like that don't need consolation any more than an alcoholic needs another drink.   They need to learn how to stand on their own two feet and stop looking for consolation every time "life happens."

    I find these "emotional black holes" can be found in just about any spiritual community, particularly the more liberal varieties, and tend to take advantage of post-modernity's embrace of "expressing your feelings," "reaching out for help," etc., in order to feed their addiction to constant support and attention. 

    I must stress I don't disagree with Amy's main point here.  I'll be the first to admit that many people need to be more willing to reach out for help, or to console those who reach out to us.  But there is another side to this issue.  Perhaps the problem is we all need to learn when it's appropriate to ask for consolation vs. when we need to stand on our own two feet.  And when others ask for consolation, I think the Bible says it far better than I can:

    "A time to cast away stones, and a time to gather stones together; a time to embrace, and a time to refrain from embracing;"

    Ecclesiastes 3:5

     

     

    –Z

  • By katie schwartz 8/22/07 at 3:55 p.m. UTC

    Excellent life lessons in this post. It feels so great to be there for the people we love. Would it kill a person to lean a little?! Oy-Oy-Oy.

Wanna post your own comments?