As an assimilated Negro, I find
that black Jews just tickle my fancy. (Any Oprah/Sarah Silverman hybrids, call me!) I agree with the
writer Julius Lester when he says,
“What I find remarkable about Jews: They’re the only ethnic group that seems to
care about blacks. At least Jews want to learn.”
I’ve certainly tried to learn a
Jewish girl a thing or two on blacks, so I figured Julius Lester might have
some words of wisdom for me. I first discovered Lester when I stumbled upon his
must-read 1984 New York Times interview
with James Baldwin (during which Baldwin exclaimed “Fuck Norman Mailer!”
when Lester mentioned the author of “The White Negro”—sadly, the Times struck it from the record.) Besides being an academic and literary
star—he's author of over 45 books and a decorated professor emeritus at
the University of Massachusetts—Lester also happens to be that most
intriguing of exotic birds, a black Jew.
He made a name for himself as a writer, radio commentator, and avowed
atheist during the civil rights era, but converted to Judaism in 1982 after
years of religious searching (Lovesong, his spiritual memoir, details this journey.)
At 68, Lester is still writing; next spring HarperCollins will publish his novel about lynching, told from the point of view of a 14-year-old white boy. I took to asking him some questions over e-mail.
I think the average black
person is suspicious when the average Jewish guy distinguishes himself from the
average white guy—at least in America. What do minorities like
blacks or Hispanics have in common with American Jews, and what are their
differences?
Not a huge fan of Normal Mailer: BaldwinIdentity has many faces, and
one’s social identity may not correspond to one’s personal identity. There
are Jews whose personal and/or religious identity is so forceful that they
resent being identified as white, even though they look like “the average white
guy.” Someone who identifies first as a Jew sees him or herself as living
by a value structure that believes in justice and equality as opposed to a
white guy whose value system is different. Perhaps blacks should not be so
quick to dismiss a Jew who insists that he is not white, regardless of what he
looks like.
Growing up in the forties and fifties, I always thought Jews were different from whites. Jews were people who empathized with blacks, who understood what it was like to be discriminated against. When I was doing radio on WBAI from 1968 to 1975, people would call me on the air and identify themselves as being “white and Jewish,” and that always confused me because, in my mind, Jews were different from white people.
None of this is to say that Jewish racism does not exist, because it does. And black racism exists, despite those who maintain that blacks cannot be racists because they are victims of racism.
It is increasingly difficult to generalize about blacks, Hispanics, and Jews because of increasing class differences within each group as well as generational differences. For example, blacks and Jews of my generation and older worked together in the labor movement and the civil rights movement. As fraught with tensions as black-Jewish relations became, that coalition meant something. The present generation of blacks and Jews do not see why it is expected that blacks and Jews will work together. The black-Jewish coalition means nothing to them, and I would not argue with that. The events of their lifetimes—Farrakhan, Israel, Arabs—mean very different things to each group.
Different from the rest of the country: Unique New York
However, having said that, black-Jewish tensions have been more pronounced in New York than, for
example, in the Midwest, where I found blacks and Jews working together
on many issues with none of the suspicion and antagonism that can exist
in New York. People too often think that the experiences of blacks
and Jews in New York reflect the state of affairs between blacks
and Jews across the country, but that is not the case.
I know it’s difficult for New Yorkers to believe that their
experiences do not represent the truth for everyone in America, but
New York is unique.
Politically I think blacks and Jews made a huge mistake in the 1980s and 1990s by not reaching out to start working with Hispanic groups. Even twenty years ago, demographic projections suggested that Hispanics were going to become the largest minority group early in the 21st century. That has happened earlier than anyone predicted. As Hispanics become an increasingly strong political group, the public discourse on whom and what constitutes a minority will change, and neither blacks nor Jews are prepared to deal with the shift. Blacks are in the process of losing their golden status as the largest minority group, and this loss is going to have an impact on black identity, which has been too focused for too long on being victims.
Is there a statute of
limitations on historical tragedies?
For how long is Auschwitz or Jim Crow Mississippi relevant to a young
Jew or Negro in New York City?
Compassion fatigue: Remember the Maine?
A very interesting question. I
suppose one needs to ask if there is a statute of
limitations on memory. There was the recent article in the
Sunday Times about people who are
tired of memorial services for the victims
of 9/11—about “compassion fatigue”. The article referred to
the numerous events that were once remembered by public
ceremonies and are scarcely remembered now: the sinking of the
USS Maine, the bombing of Pearl Harbor.
One of the real problems facing
America today is that since the 1960s, Americans no
longer share the same historical memories, or we do
not share those memories in the same ways.
In the summer of 1973 I taught
summer school at a small college in Macon, Georgia. In one of my classes
was a very beautiful blonde girl who invited me to drive up to someplace in
north Georgia with her. I declined. I knew that
northern Georgia was prime KKK territory and as much as I wanted to
sleep with her, driving into Klan country was a price I was not willing to
pay. When she asked me why I told her about the Klan’s prominence in
northern Georgia, about segregation and the backs of buses, etc. She
looked at me with her wide blue eyes like I was crazy said in her honeyed
southern accent “None of that ever happened down here.”
Echoes of the past: Jim Crow Mississippi can't be forgotten
Even though she was blonde,
she was not dumb. She had come of age after the changes wrought by the civil
rights movement and had grown up at a time when blacks sat anywhere on buses,
when there were no white and colored water fountains in stores, when
blacks and whites went to school together. I was floored by her
response. I had no idea that history could be wiped out so completely in so
short a time. This was 1973. The summer
nine years before, I had been in Mississippi waking up every morning
half-surprised that I hadn’t been killed during the night. After that day
I didn’t know how to talk to her, (which was sad because she was
really a beautiful girl) because her experience negated the history I
had endured.
It is not enough that
we remember only what happened to us. We should make the effort to
remember that which happened to others, even others before
we were born. So many U.S. states and cities have Native
American names. The people are gone; all that remains is a word from
their language, which is really a kind of tombstone. Massachusetts is
a Native American word meaning “High Mountain Place.” Connecticut means
“Long River Place.” It is my obligation to remember. The act of
remembering connects us to each other. The life of the young black in New York
grows from the lives and deaths of blacks in Mississippi who
endured and struggled so that he would not have to endure and struggle in
quite the same ways. The same goes for the young Jew.
Still relevant?: Building the Holocaust Memorial in Berlin
Our lives do not begin
with our births. Our lives exist on a continuum. Part of that
continuum is that our lives today will become someone
else’s past, and how we live our lives will, to some degree, give
texture and context to the lives of people not yet born.
One of the things I love about
being Jewish is that remembering is an integral part of
being Jewish. On Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur we sing melodies and say
prayers that date back a thousand years and more. On Tisha B’Av we still
mourn the destruction of the Temple in Jerusalem more than 2000 years ago. At
Passover we remember the exodus from Egypt, which may or may not have
happened, but something happened that was transformative.
It is my wish that the young
black New Yorker will remember Auschwitz as well as Jim Crow Mississippi,
and that the young Jewish New Yorker will remember Jim Crow Mississippi
as well as Auschwitz. Remembering the sufferings of others makes
us come closer to each other.
Seems to be being a black Jew
might have some perks. For example you can’t be “out-victimized” by
anyone, right? It also seems the particular black-Jew blend should have a
nickname. Any suggestions?
If
there are perks to being a black Jew, I missed out. And
I must be dumber than I realized because it never occurred
to me that no one could out-victimize me. I never thought of being
black or Jewish as being a victim, which just goes to demonstrate
how much out of touch I am with the times I live in.
As for nicknames, oy vey! Virginia Hamilton wrote a novel called Bluish about a kid who was black and Jewish, but “bluish” sounds more like an alien in a bad Sci-Fi movie. The police chief (or maybe he’s former police chief now) of Charleston, South Carolina is (was) a black man named Reuben Greenberg, and he is Jewish. He said he was working on a recipe for fried chicken soup. That’s as close to black-Jewish humor as I’ve seen.
You’re a blogger at 68, when
many people your age are still trying to get on to the Internet. Do you
think it's important to stay engaged with the youth generation? Do you think
blogs are a good medium for bridging generational gaps?
The non-linear world: Can you blog and walk at the same time?
There are probably more people my
age online than is recognized. I think it is important to stay
engaged with the youth generation to the degree that
is possible. I taught at the University of
Massachusetts for 32 years, retiring at the end of
2003. I retired in part because I couldn’t continue to bridge
the generational difference between my students and me.
Yes, I blog but Facebook, YouTube, and other such
enterprises are beyond me. At age 68, I keep having to decide: Given however
much time I have left, how do I want to use it? One of my
children is on Facebook and I enjoy logging in and
seeing what she’s up to, but I don’t have the time or energy to
create a Facebook site for myself.
One difference that my
daughter and I talk about is that I grew up in a
“linear world,” i.e. the world of print, and also a world in
which you did one thing at a time. She has grown
up in a world of simultaneity, a world in which one
does several things simultaneously. It took me a while
to understand that I can be talking to a friend in France on Skype
and at the same time being sending that friend an attachment relating to
what we’re talking about. And there’re probably four other things I could
be doing at the same time. I grew up taking piano
lessons; my daughter grew up with Garageband. A big difference.
I want to stay
engaged with younger generations but recognize that I
can only do so to a limited extent. Aging has its
own interesting challenges and rewards. One is relief that I won’t
be young again; another is the ability to look back to when
I was young and what my dreams were and being able to say
that I have achieved what I set out to achieve and more, that I
didn’t sell out, that I made my
dreams become reality. I would not trade being 68 for anything.
Are there any classic writers
that would have thrived in this new media environment?
The Perez Hilton of Dublin: Joyce (drawn in text)
This is a very interesting question.
The writer who first comes to mind is Malcolm Lowery. I don’t
remember the name of the novel, but one of his novels has a
separate text running in the margin next to the main text. I
wrote a short story (“The Child,” published in Join
In: Multiethnic Short Stories) and a
novella (“Catskill Morning,” published in Two
Love Stories) in which I attempted to
tell two stories—one in the margin, the other the
main text. And I think James Joyce would have
excelled in this new environment. To be able to add visuals
to stream of consciousness feels like a natural for him. Although he’s not
a writer, certainly Picasso would have thrived on the kind
of art that is possible now, which can combine text, visuals, and
sound.
I went with
Baldwin one day to help him buy an electric typewriter. It
frightened him so, I don’t think he ever used it.
What blogs do you read?
You mentioned seeing me on Gawker.
I read Gawker, Jezebel, The Assimilated Negro, and several blogs devoted to women’s fashions. I love women’s fashions and subscribe to Vogue, Paris Vogue, Harper’s Bazaar, W, and a couple of others. Both Gawker and Jezebel are funny as hell. The contributors on both have raised cynicism to a height that has its own peculiar beauty. However, Gawker needs to lighten up on the cracks about old people.
Links:
[1] http://theassimilatednegro.blogspot.com/
[2] http://www.jewishsf.com/content/2-0-/module/displaystory/story_id/2972/edition_id/52/format/html/displaystory.html
[3] http://www.nytimes.com/books/98/03/29/specials/baldwin-reflections.html?_r=1&oref=slogin
[4] http://www.amazon.com/Lovesong-Becoming-Jew-Julius-Lester/dp/1559703164/ref=pd_bbs_sr_2/105-4756142-8034019?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1191527914&sr=8-2
[5] http://www.amazon.com/Join-Multiethnic-Donald-R-Gallo/dp/0440219574/ref=sr_1_1/105-4756142-8034019?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1191601102&sr=8-1
[6] http://www.amazon.com/Two-Love-Stories-Lester/dp/0803791453/ref=sr_1_4/105-4756142-8034019?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1191601160&sr=1-4
[7] http://www.gawker.com/
[8] http://jezebel.com/
[9] http://www.theassimilatednegro.blogspot.com/