Sun, Sep 07, 2008

User login

Today in Terrifying Ad Campaigns

New ads promote social justice, scare the crap out of people
 

Headed Towards Your House!: Oh wait, just kiddingHeaded Towards Your House!: Oh wait, just kidding Introducing the newest trend in social justice: the terrifying ad campaign. Social justice organizations are out to get your attention, and they’re willing to scare the crap out of you in the process.

Let’s take the new series of ads being run by the American Jewish Committee for example. Imagine you are sitting down to a nice, relaxing dinner at home.You’re in the mood for some good classical music, so you switch on WQXR, the most notoriously non-offensive public radio station in New York.After a lovely set of tunes, it’s time for a word from the sponsors.You hear, “Imagine you had 15 seconds to find shelter from an incoming missile. Fifteen seconds to locate your children, help an elderly relative, assist a disabled person to find shelter…”Whoa!

You’re about to duck and cover under your kitchen table in fear when you catch the rest of the ad: “That's all the residents of Sderot and neighboring Israeli towns have. Day or night, the sirens go on. Fifteen seconds later, the missiles, fired from Hamas-controlled Gaza, hit . . . Their aim is to kill and wound and demoralize . . . This is what Israelis experience daily.”

How scary is this ad?Scary enough for WQXR to pull it.The station’s general manager Tom Bartunek has explained this decision, saying the ad was “outside our bounds of acceptability. First, the opening line . . . does not make clear that the potential target of the missile is not our listening area, and as a consequence, runs the risk of raising anxiety in a misleading way.”

Unfortunately, AJC spokesman Michael Geller does not feel the same way.He says, "It's unbelievable. At the end of the day, WQXR listeners are interested in Israel.”The AJC has terminated its contract with the station, maintaining the statement, “It's a shame, but we can't allow ourselves to be edited on a whim."At least from now on WQXR listeners will be able to sleep easy.

Watch Out, Riders!: You never know when the Nazis might attackWatch Out, Riders!: You never know when the Nazis might attackThe terrifying ad campaign is not limited to conservative classical music channels. Let’s take this scenario over to MTV. Imagine you’re catching up with your favorite “characters” on the Hills when the broadcast is interrupted by one of these ads. They start out with ordinary people in an ordinary situation -- watching TV or riding the subway. But things quickly start to go awry: The people get rounded up by scary men with guns and flashlights until everyone on screen is rearranged into a snapshot from a Nazi concentration camp and the words “The Holocaust happened to people like us” appears in bold on the screen.

Now, unlike WQXR, MTV would have no trouble running an ad for condoms or hemorrhoid cream.Even so, these ads are a bit much.

The most upsetting part?They never even say what they are for.You wouldn’t know it by watching, but these commercials are MTV’s way of getting introducing its youngster demographic with the discrimination and genocide going on in Darfur.Unfortunately, this connection is only made by going to the prescribed website…and then searching around a little bit.Instead, the viewer is left shaking in her little Ugg boots thinking that the modern day Gestapo is about to bust through her living room door.



 

Phantom


They Work!

Obviously, the intended affect/goal is to get people to the mtv website.  If you tell the audience what the ad is about, they won't go to the website.

The secondary goal is to get young people to actually think about the horror, and maybe experience it in some small way.  And why shouldn't we do this?  Why is it any worse than watching a Marilyn Manson video or any number of horrifying videos that MTV broadcasts?  At least it's for a good and just cause.  Their contemporaries in Darfur are actually living these horrors.  So it's not such a high price to pay in the grand scheme of things to shock our youngsters just a little bit to get them to think, learn, sympathize and maybe, God forbid, get off the couch and take some action.





geminijinx


Good campaigns...

...make people think.

I think we're all to apathetic and complacent these days and people generally think "oh, that can't happen to me" but these ads show that it can and it does/did happen to people just like us.

Ads that are too 'nice' and 'pretty' don't work. While I think both these ads are shocking (and not meaning bad), the situations themselves are shocking people need to be woken up from their comfortable lives and made to realise that there are people like them suffering everyday.





epgeller


WQXR

Hi, Jessica,

I never would have heard of you, or even of Jewcy, had I not read a blog critical of you today on Z-Word (a website of the American Jewish Committee), but that is another story. When I clicked on your blog, I thought I was going to find something awful. Instead, I found a thoughtful, ironic, wonderful piece which I personally consider to be in the best tradition of Jewish humor and culture. We can debate all day and night whether WQXR was right or wrong, but as a father of a young lady in college who would have written exactly as you did, I say, "Bravo." 





Tzveee


WQXR

epgeller and I are on the same exact page (except "brava" for "bravo.")





yossi benayoun


WQXR and epgeller

Gotta take my yarmulke off to ep geller. Dude, you wrote a comment that was even more stupid than this article. Who gives a shit if jessica makes you go misty-eyed? She doesn't care about sderot, she doesn't care about darfur, she can't do satire. You and she should get your sorry asses to Sderot - with or without Ugg boots. You might just learn something.

Schmuck.





Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Use <!--pagebreak--> to create page breaks.
  • HTML tags will be transformed to conform to HTML standards.
  • Images can be added to this post.

More information about formatting options

Captcha
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.