
![]() |
10 Things We Can Learn From Evangelical Christians |
|
by Patrick Aleph, August 12, 2009 |
||
I live in the Bible Belt, so I know a thing-or-two (or twelve) about the Religious Right in this country. The one thing I know for sure: they are smart as shit.
Am I saying that I want to leave the Chosen People for Protestant Paradise? Fuck no! But I do have to give credit where credit is due.
See, the Evangelicals in this country are amazing communicators, sales people, networkers. All the things that Jews pride themselves on being, Christians have managed to do, times one-thousand. And it's time that we learned the secrets of the Christian world, in order to better improve things for our slice of society.
What I have done is laid out ten things that I watch my Evangelical neighbors do, that I feel would strengthen the Jewish community. Call it, "Habits of Highly Effective Hebrews."
FreeBreakfast: if you want to see the smartest Christian ministry inthe world, visit www.freebreakfastchurch.com. The site of The Courageous Church (an urban, contemporary evangelical ministry),"Free Breakfast Church" offers free breakfast every Sunday, open to the public. You are invited afterwards to attend services, but are not compelled. It's better than one of those Timeshare Condo deals! And it works. The church is growing like a wildfire.
The funny part is, they stole this from the Jewish tradition; oneg is an important part of the Shabbat ritual. So why not take the oneg concept, and flip it on its head. "Free Dinner Synagogue" could open up the floodgates to new people taking part in the Jewish experience. To stay in accordance with kashrut, meals would be vegetarian...or better yet...vegan! A Kabbalat Shabbat with vegandinner would be huge in metropolitan areas!
Having Some Fucking Pride: an annoying thing about the Christian Evangelicals: they're just so full of themselves. And damn right for it. They think they have the monopoly on the afterlife. Wouldn't that make you feel proud, too?
Jewish pride is a strange thing. We're proud about surviving Hitler and our kugel recipes, but you never see Jews openly talking about the transformative experience of lighting a menorah or watching your child's bar/bat mitzvah. Christians will go on for hours about how great Jesus has been in their lives. Jews will go on for hours about how they saved money on their car insurance. The bottom line is that we need to make Jewish spirituality so magical that it makes you bust apart at the seams.
Make Denominations Irrelevant: luckily this is already happening,although the different "brain trusts" in the Reform, Conservative, Orthodox and Reconstructionist movements are trying their best to combat it. The Evangelical movement is decentralized,yet they talk about "The Church" as if all Christians, regardless if they go to Faith Harvest Ministry or Harvesting Faith Ministry, are a part of one body.
Jews tend to pick their shul based on family background, location, whether ornot they feel like they "fit in" with the congregation andif the synagogue addresses their issues the way they want them to. But in reality, the distinction between Conservative and Reform, Reconstructionist and Renewal is blurred beyond belief. This will help us a lot by getting more Jews involved in fewer congregations. This concentration of power, with the right tools and leadership, could create a Jewish Spiritual Renaissance.
Getting Involved: it's all about Tikkun Olam, baby! The problem is, when we try to repair the world "Jewishly", our Jewishness tends to overshadow the good we are trying to do. Saving Darfur is great, but relying on Holocaust guilt and the local Jewish Museum to help is not the way to do it. And come one, people, not everything has to dowith Israel or Zionism!
If you look at Christian ministries that work in social activism, the heart of "why" they do it is the love of G_d. When you look atwhy Jews do social activism, it seems to be less invigorated. We dothings because its "the right thing to do" but this doesn't have the spiritual power that it needs to convey the importance of the mission. Instead of saying, "Jews believe in Tikkun Olam, so we started an anti-hunger program, hope you like it", Jews should say, "G_d commands us to feed every poor person in the world. By donating to the food bank, you are doing G_d's will on Earth. Would you like to be a part of G_d's plan?"
Reaching Out To Young People: Christian Hardcore was the best thing that happened to the Christian community in the past twenty years. And they capitalized on it: Christian record labels, the Christian version of Youtube, Rock For Life rallies. This is all an effort to bring people to Jesus through a medium that works.
Jews could do this. Websites like G-dcast.com break the mold of Judaism by injecting youth culture into Jewish tradition, in a spiritually positive way. I hope that the lyrics I write in my band Can!!Can do the same. JDub Records is another great leader, introducing the worldto new artists that give a pro-spirituality spin to the otherwise secular Jewish world.
The key to reaching young people is to not have an agenda, speak their language, and be honest. Church basement shows do not involve preaching,tattoos and piercings are welcome and the music is good. Sure, limits are placed on drinking/smoking/violence/foul language, but other than that, it's a free for all. There's no reason why synagogues couldn't do the same thing.
Create New Traditions: this is something that I've seen the Evangelical World do, really well. Ever heard about "Hell Houses", the Evangelical version of a haunted house which literally scares-the-devil-out-of-you? Or what about Promise Rings and Abstinence Pledges? These are all the new traditions of the Christian faith, and Jews could do the same thing. And in fact, some already do.
I love the line, "the spirit of our tradition is innovation." I stole that from Rabbi Josh Lesser, the openly gay rabbi at Congregation Bet Haverim in Atlanta. Rabbi Josh has done some cool stuff over his ten-year tenure at CBH, including the Mount Sinai Mountain of Ice Cream on Shavuot and the free-form Passover Seder, where the entire congregation was asked to shout out the Passover story, in any order they chose with Rabbi Josh simply connecting-the-dots to create a linear tale. This guy is a great example of creating your own tradition, when there isn't one already there.
Reach Out To People: Jews have this bizarre "if we build it, they will come" attitude about houses of prayer. We somehow think that if we create a congregation and let Jews know about it, that people will naturally come in. Once we have them in, we just worry about keeping them there.
Christians see it differently. They see any opportunity to get-the-word-out about their church as some kind of divine mandate. When I go to the county fair, I'm surrounded by church booth after church booth, many of the same Southern-Bapti-Costal blood. But they push and push to make themselves known.
Jews, traditionally, don't care. We get some families together, pool somemoney together for siddur and oneg, and hope to one day have a building with a bitchin' Judaica giftshop and day care center.
If we really cared about what we are doing, we'd get out there more! So many secular, atheist and unaffiliated Jews would have interest in what your synagogue had to offer, if only you would throw them a rope. People don't often go "searching" for a spiritual home. Often, it takes a caring person to bring them in.
So myquestion to you is, which of these habits are you going to pick up?
kleehammer
Dude, you are too hilarious. I was halfway through the article before I figured out who wrote it. I'll see you in Baltimore on the 19th!
- The Real Hebrew Hammer
JulesGP76
What a great article - I love an author who is not afraid to use crude languages where crude language is due!!!
Recruiting_Animal
1. Evangelical Christians live in the midst of a huge Christian-community. To reach all they have to do is grab the person beside them - wherever they are.
2. Mainstream Judaism is not in the business of transformative experience.That's why its losing spiritually minded people to Buddhism.
3. Most Jews do not believe literally in biblical mythology. So it's hard for them to go around shouting about it from the rooftops even if they really enjoy being Jewish.
4. Numbers again. If you are recruiting from a large community, you only have to sign up a small percentage to have a good sized movement. The Jewish community is small to begin with.
Jeff Eyges
and I'd add that evangelicals increase their numbers through the use of one or both of the following:
1. They use the fear of eternal damnation to strong-arm people who suffer from pathologically low self-esteem, and are, tragically, prepared to believe they deserve nothing better;
2. They then offer the experience (imaginary or not) of "relationship" with a being who loves them unconditionally (this is how it's expressed, although, of course, there is a condition - "Love God or you'll burn in hell")
These are not our tactics, and, although the Hareidim indulge in threats of damnation far more often than most secular Jews are aware of or are comfortable admitting, we really have no theological foundation upon which to base a strategy of coercion.
Noam Chofsky
i think Jewish communities are already doing all of these things (maybe not all at the same time), and they don't really work to pull in the Jewish masses. The problem is not straedgy, it's just that Jews are overly-intellectual and materialistic. Aside from the ultra-orthodox, we just aren't in a period of spiritual renaissance. Sit it out, because there could be one in 100 - 300 years.
Robin Margolis
Dear Patrick Aleph:
This is a very great article. I have repeatedly suggested these techniques to Jewish outreach groups in charge of seeking out interfaith families and disaffiliated Jews.
Jewish groups outreaching interfaith families have tried some of them, modifying them to fit Jewish communities. Slowly, some of these tactics are starting to work.
However -- at least to my perception -- others may differ -- some Jewish communities don't have enough spiritual or cultural "belief capital" left to make many of these tactics work with Jews from inmarried familes (Jews with two Jewish parents), never mind interfaith families.
Some Jews -- not all -- don't themselves have enough belief in spiritual or cultural Judaism to convincingly sell it to the 49% of all Jews in America who are disaffiliated from the Jewish community.
Even some Jewish outreach listserves for interfaith families tend to spend endless hours debating "should we give interfaith couples Purim baskets this year?" That's not exactly an inspring outreach message.
As you noted, many Jews have substituted belief in Zionism and Israel -- and Holocaust commemoration -- for the active spiritual or cultural practice of Judaism itself -- they no longer believe in it, so cling to Israel and the Holocaust as their sole Jewish "markers."
Israel and the Holocaust will not be effective props for Jewish identity much longer --- the Holocaust and the founding of Israel already nearly 70 years in the past.
The missing factor in your article is the growing prevalence of interfaith families in Judaism. Paradoxically, because these families have at least one Christian parent or grandparent, they are more willng to respond to these types of outreach tactics.
Hopefully, as the Jewish population shifts increasingly to the intermarried and adult children of intermarriage, the eminently sensible tactics that you suggest will be adopted more widely, by mixed-heritage Jewish families that will actually be enthusiastic about the spiritual and cultural content of Judaism.
I hope you will keep making useful suggestions, as I enjoy reading them.
Cordially,
Robin Margolis
www.half-jewish.net
Jeff Eyges
Aside from the ultra-orthodox, we just aren't in a period of spiritual renaissance.
The Hareidim are hardly going through a period of "spiritual renaissance". It's quite the opposite - they've descended into a state of xenophobia and uncompromising dogmatism. Their world is collapsing; they're succumbing to pressure from without and deterioration from within. They have perhaps two genreations left, at most - and recent developments lead me to believe it may not even take that long.
Unfortunately, they've also subsumed most of Orthodxy. When they go, they'll be taking all but the most liberal factions of Modern Orthodxy with them.
smokesteam
Where I live theres darn few Jews, lots of times we dont even have a minyan for Shabbat. The only "get the word out" stuff is done here by Chabad. In a big way I'm fine with that, before I was a Jew, pushy Christians really got under my fingernails. OTOH though, I'll admit we really could do more here, especially since we do so darn little that I can see.
punktorah
punktorah
Sometimes you just have to drop the F Bomb.
Zeevico
I don't think Jews have that much of a problem with reading the word "free."
(Badum-tis)
Ella
Hi Patrick Aleph
I really enjoyed your article. But do you think a free lunch is going to make people want to swallow the rest of the Faith? Bapticostals have it easy, their theology is just "Accept Jesus, get a (guaranteed) ticket to heaven and enjoy the ride!"
The rest of us have a lot more theology and a lot more difficult theology to swallow...
Noam Chofsky
"They have perhaps two genreations left, at most - and recent developments lead me to believe it may not even take that long. " - Jeff Eyges.
What will happen in 2 generations? Do you think they will:
a) assimilate into the NY and Palestinian goyim;
b) turn to reform judaism
c) have a new haskalah
d) relax into modern orthodoxy
?
I think they will only gain in confidence and numbers. Their society isn't perfect but they will find the answers to deal with these issues on their own terms....
NeuBill
Patrick,
You may not need to reach out at all. In fact, I believe the synagogues may see a big growth spurt in the form of converts to Judaism.
If anyone has noticed, the last 5-10 years has seen the Judaica industry get back on it's feet because of Christians who desire to connect with the Hebraic roots of their faith. Mezuzahs, shabbat sets, taleism, kippot, siddurim, and even tefillot are being sold to Christians who want more than what they're getting from The Church. They want to observe the mo'edim, have kabbalat shabbat, study Torah (and Talmud!), have Kabbalat Shabbat, and pray the way Yeshua prayed. There are many who left The Church because the Pastor/Minister/Priest not only didn't embrace the Hebraic roots of Christianity, but condemned them for 'going under The Law' as it's written by Sha'ul of Tarsus in the Apostolic Scriptures (New Testament). The Hebrew Roots movement in Christianity is growing and if these people do not have access to a Messianic Synagogue, guess where they're going to go? And they'll definitely bring something Kosher to oneg, although it takes them a little bit longer to understand separating meat from dairy.