Posts

Compassion for Craig

By toast / August 29, 2007

As funny as this and this may be, it gets tiresome really quickly. It’s not that Rebublican hypocrisy re: homosexuality shouldn’t be publicized, but the immediate and widespread glee buries the actual seriousness and does Liberals a disservice in the long run.  Think about it: wouldn’t absolute silence, or, since  that’s impossible, simply straightforward reporting, be a curious but effective way for Liberals to say what they need to say without saying it, gain steam, Move On? Republicans are taking care of themselves, anyway.

Leave it to Jamie Kirchick, guest blogging for A. Sullivan, to dig beyond the headlines and continue to show compassion—even when many will argue it’s unwarranted— for Craig. It’s an almost Christian, unbearably wise, move on his part:

 In the fall of 1955, 12 men were arrested in Boise, Idaho for "infamous crimes against nature." Over a decade, it had been alleged, some of the city's most prominent men operated an underworld gay prostitution ring with hundreds of teenage boys. A story in Time, published after the scandal emerged, characterized the feelings of the day : "Boise, Idaho (pop. 50,000), the state capital, is usually thought of as a boisterous, rollicking he-man's town, and home of the rugged Westerner." How shocking, then, that there could be gay people living there. One of the more humane participants in this episode was the chief of the state's Department of Mental Health, who, rather than advocate that the men face jail time, offered that, "One alternative might be to let them form their own society and be left alone."

 There's a documentary film about this episode called "The Fall of '55."

 Initial claims that over a hundred boys were abused were exaggerated; only four or five boys were involved. But lives were ruined, gay men fled the city, and the sexual witch-hunt left a stamp on the state. Larry Craig is just one of the more public victims of the cultural atmosphere in this country that portrays homosexuality as disgusting and something of which to be ashamed. There are many, silent sufferers like him. You could see his shame in yesterday's press conference, and that the specter of Boise, 1955 has hung over Larry Craig all his life.

 Shit. Maybe he is human, after all. 

POST A COMMENT

  • Mason Lerner
    By Mason Lerner 8/31/07 at 1:54 p.m. UTC

    What did the guy really do wrong? He wasn't soliciting a prostitute. He touched another guy's foot with his. That's a crime?

    And the "wide stance" defense made me happy inside the way you feel on a perfect Spring day, when the wind is just right, the leaves are rustling and the sun is shining on your beaming face.

    The audio of the interview really makes the whole thing smell like a ham and cheese sandwich. Also, I can't understand why they wouldn't just post a uniformed officer in the restroom if they wanted to curtail sex in the stalls.

    I also can't understand how Craig caved. He should have told the cop,"I'm under arrest? You're under arrest once I call homeland security. I heard you planning a terrorist act on this very airport while you were in the john. Have fun in Gitmo. No room for wide stances there."

    Doesn't Craig know that he is the one that should be trampling on others' civil rights? What made him forget?

  • By zbird 8/30/07 at 7:36 p.m. UTC

    Of course, none of us know what happened in the stall, but if you listen long enough to the tape you feel sorry for Craig and wonder why the police have nothing better to do than pick  on this guy:

    http://video.msn.com/v/us/fv/msnbc/fv.htm??f=00&g=63b5e068-2cb0-427f-a0dd-14b27890336d&p=source_no_ad_nbc&t=m5&rf=http://www.msnbc.msn.com/&fg= 

     

    –Z

  • Tamar Fox
    By Tamar Fox 8/30/07 at 7:30 p.m. UTC

    I would do that, too, Mike.  Jk…

  • Michael Weiss
    By Michael Weiss 8/30/07 at 6:14 p.m. UTC

    He gets on my computer and reads my Skypes with my GF.

  • François Blumenfeld-Kouchner
    By François Blumenfeld-Kouchner 8/30/07 at 6:11 p.m. UTC

    Tamar -Hang on, this is NOT about Jewcy’s Craig? Are you sure? That really sounds like him. Especially the part about how he may be human, after all.

  • Tamar Fox
    By Tamar Fox 8/29/07 at 11:38 p.m. UTC

    When I first read the headline I thought this was in reference to Jewcy's Craig, and I was like, "Wait, what did he do??"

     

Wanna post your own comments?