Fri, Sep 05, 2008

User login

THE CABAL
Hollow Criticism from Boyd and Yglesias

Sam Boyd has issued a lengthy non-response response to my post criticizing his calling Ayaan Hirsi Ali, in my mind (and in the minds of many others) "The Bravest, Most Remarkable Woman of Our Times," a "dangerous fanatic." However, he avoids debate on this subject to instead attack me for something I wrote on contentions about two disturbing endorsements Barack Obama received in the past several weeks.Since Boyd doesn't want to engage in a debate about his outrageous and scurrilous slandering of this woman, I'll respond to his scattershot and largely incoherent defense of the racist thug and Robert Mugabe fan Charles Barron and Donnie "the gays want to 'kill our children'" McClurkin's endorsment of Barack Obama for president.

A few quick things of which to dispense:

  • As for Charles Barron, the most Boyd can muster is that he's "rather unpleasant." He then chides me for linking to a piece I wrote about Barron as my "source on Barron's faults." Sam should do some reading on New York City politics before commenting so impetuously about Charles Barron, but here's some other stories about his endorsing the assassination of one of his Council colleagues and his hosting Robert Mugabe in Council chambers.
  • Boyd writes that my "casual dismissal of Jesse Jackson as a 'racial huckster' is extra special classy." Not sure what he's getting at here, but if it's an attempt to say that Jesse Jackson deserves anything more than "casual dismissal" from serious people and that he isn't a "racial huckster," then Boyd's just beyond the reach of rational discussion. Charles Barron, by the way, makes Jesse Jackson seem like Bayard Rustin.

Matthew Yglesias joins the pile-on, and while the post is more grammatically coherent than his usual, fobbed off prose, it still makes no sense so there's nothing I can really offer in reply.

While we're on the subject of presidential endorsements, I already see that liberals at Tapped and elsewhere are making hay over Pat Robertson's endorsement of Rudy Giuliani. They should. It's slimy. And you can argue all you want that Obama's association with Barron and McClurkin mean nothing (I'd actually contend that the views of Barron and McClurkin are far more reprehensible than those of Robertson), but don't simultaneously criticize the Robertson endorsement as spelling Giuliani's conversion to the religious social agenda. You can't have it both ways.

Finally, neither Boyd, Yglesias, or anyone at the Prospect has responded to my queries about Robert Dreyfuss, the magazine's "Senior Correspondent" on national security and foreign policy, who is a disciple of Lyndon LaRouche, or about their magazine's hawking his LaRouche-published book on its website. This reticence is understandable, considering how embarrassing it must be to have such an individual as a colleague at your place of employment. But that won't stop me from bringing it up.



James Kirchick is an assistant editor of The New Republic and is a columnist for the Washington Blade and Washington Examiner.


More...

Daniel Koffler


Robertson and Giuliani

I can't speak for anyone at Tapped, but I would think the right interpretation of the Robertson endorsement is as a transparently cynical move by both parties, and a means for Rudy to solidify his "terrorism is more important than abortion" theme, rather than a very subtle gesture that he's part of the flock on social issues.





Jesse


Er...

I'm still trying to decipher the first sentence of this post. Who said what about who now?





Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Use <!--pagebreak--> to create page breaks.
  • HTML tags will be transformed to conform to HTML standards.
  • Images can be added to this post.

More information about formatting options

Captcha
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.