| The Friday 5: Top Trayf Cravings | |
|
by Leah Koenig, October 26, 2007
|
|

An observant friend of mine celebrates Purim every year with a ‘trayf night -” the one night a year he willingly – even actively – eats non-kosher food. Purim, he figures, is all about shaking things up and turning daily realities upside down (well, that and getting wasted). What better night to indulge in all the delicious trayf foods he abstains from the rest of the year?
Whether you’re a total trayf abstainer, an occasional trayfer, or an everyday trayf eater – here is a list of the unkosher foods that Jews love to hate.
Shrimp Cocktail – Shrimp started the Reform movement – no really! According to Wikipedia, “On July 11, 1883, a dinner was held in Cincinnati celebrating the ordination of the Reform Jewish seminary's first class of rabbis. It was a sumptuous feast of Little Neck clams on the half shell, soft-shell crab and shrimp salad, along with beef fillet and ice cream. The meal quickly gained notoriety for abrogating every rule of kashrut, the Jewish dietary laws, except the prohibition against pork.” Judaism never tasted so good!
Bacon Cheeseburger – What other food offers not one, but three different opportunities (milk and meat, unkosher beef, and sweet, sweet bacon) to trayf it up in one, delicious bite? All the melty, porky goodness…the thought even makes this vegetarian a little weak in the knees.
Lobster – Remember that beautiful blond girl who sat in your English Lit class at Princeton? You know the one. She ate lobster – she ate it on beautiful china at the family country club, delicately cracking open the claws and dipping the meat in a rich buttery sauce? Keep dreaming yid kids - lobster may be fancy and sophisticated, but it’s trayfer than the day is long.
Clam Chowder – Whether you prefer the creamy white kind from New England, or the tomato-tinged version from Manhattan, there’s no denying that a bowl of warm clam chowder dotted with salty oyster crackers holds a special place on a cold, rainy day. Unless you don’t eat clam, in which case, pass the matzah balls!
Pepperoni Pizza – When Subway went kosher, the cheese got sacked – because if you have to pick between meat and cheese, the choice for most Jews is painfully clear. Not so with pizza. Since the dawn of the first pizza, Jews have had to suffer through milchig-only pies.
![]() |
Leah Koenig is the Editor-in-Chief of The Jew and the Carrot: Hazon's Blog on Jews, Food, and Contemporary Life (www.jcarrot.org) She is also a freelance writer living in Brooklyn (as far as she knows, she's the More... |
Helen Jupiter
Shrimp in Lobster Sauce
I think this is a generational thing, or maybe it's a coastal thing, but my mom, who grew up in New Jersey, has described her family's weekly, Chinese dinners, at which they always ordered the legendarily gross sounding "Shrimp in Lobster Sauce." Talk about trayf.
Dale Raben
bacon-wrapped scallops
This appetizer is forbidden at my wedding!
Anonymous
A culinary aside: despite
A culinary aside: despite the deceptive-to-Western-ears name, lobster sauce contains not a particle of lobster. It often includes ground pork, though, just so the shrimp will have company.
Ismail
Helen Jupiter
Funny, Gross, Totally Unappetizing, Cool to Know
Thanks for sharing, Ismail. Personally, I've never tried it, but my mom has said it's mucus-like. Delish.
Anonymous
Shrimp with lobster sauce
Very tasty slop. You should try it sometimes Helen. Its works very well with shrimp. I hate when they put too much garlic in it.
Helen Jupiter
I actually trust...
...that it's pretty tasty. Sadly, I'll never know: I'm kosher by default. In other words: vegan. Maybe I can veganize it and post the recipe. Now That would be a challenge: Shrimp with Lobster sauce sans shrimp/lobster/pork... Steaming plate of air, anyone?
Anonymous
Broccoli with lobster sauce?
Lobster sauce according to Ismail has no actual lobster so its ok to eat for a Vegan. And I've only occasionally seen pork in it, so no reason not to eat it there. I think it would go very well with steamed broccoli and rice. I've often seen scrambled egg in it, which makes it quite tasty. Can you eat eggs as Vegan?
Helen Jupiter
No Eggz Allowed
However, perhaps we could scramble some tofu in. This is getting interesting! :-p
Anonymous
Helen
Tofu is a good substitute. Sounds like a dish!
It must be tough being a Vegan if you can't eat eggs. There are so many dishes which use them as 'stabilizers' so to speak. You must have a hard time eating out.
Anonymous
OK, Helen, here's what you
OK, Helen, here's what you do:
1. Mince a large clove of garlic, an inch of ginger and two Tbsp. of fermented black beans (found in vacuum sealed bags at Asian groceries). Stir-fry this chinese sofrito in a tablespoon of very hot peanut oil for about 5 seconds (you don't want the garlic to burn).
2. Immediately add a cup or so of chicken stock-oops, water or vegetable stock, a Tbsp or so of soy sauce, and a Tbsp of oyster sauce-oops, scratch the oyster sauce.
3. When the resulting mixture is simmering, throw in the slurry of cornstarch and water you've presciently composed ahead of time (1 tsp cornstarch to 2 Tbsp water-be sure to stir right before adding because the cornstarch will have settled to the bottom).
4. Pour this over steamed broccoli and warm cubes of (ugh) tofu.
5. You'll want to play around with the proportions to get the exact degree of saltiness, pungency and viscosity you like.
You're welcome.
Ismail
Anonymous
Rice
Don't forget the rice!
Cool recipe Ismail.
Reuven
Number 2 - the cheeseburger
The prohibition on mixing milk and meat applies only to kosher meat. Trayf meat, since it's already 'Trayf' doesnot have a prohibition of mixing with dairy products.
Lkoenig23
Fascinating
So what you're saying, Reuven, if I hear you correctly, is that bacon cheesburgers are only treyf in two ways instead of three...they're practically kosher! ;-)
Helen Jupiter
Ismail
Holy Moses, you should start a vegan food blog!!
By the way, you're right. It can be a real bitch eating out. Luckily I'm a whiz in the kitchen. :-p
Lys H
A major omission!
Lasagne.
Seriously. The thought of a future bereft of lasagne is pretty much what stands between me and conversion...
Post new comment