Sat, Oct 11, 2008

User login

Shvitz Search


Jewcy Book Club

Welcome Authors
Brian Frazer
&
Mike Edison
who are posting all week.
Coming up:
  • 10/13:
    Rabbi Levi Brackman and Sam Jaffe
  • 10/20:
    Jonathan Garfinkel
  • 10/20:
    Rabbi Robert Levine
  • 10/27:
    Danit Brown
  • 10/27:
    Joshua Henkin
  • 11/03:
    Craig Glazer
  • 11/10:
    Max Gross
  • 11/17:
    Seth Greenland

Contribute


Featured Book

Featured Album



DAILY SHVITZ
Plastic + Water Bottle = Satan
TAGS:

Quench your thirstI remember learning as a preteen that Evian spelled backwards is NAIVE.  That day, I lost a part of my innocence and reverie with the goodness of the world.  Today, my favorite irreverant environmental magazine, Grist, quipped "Evian Is Just Evil Misspelled." 

Stellar headline aside, they have a point.  20 years ago, hardly anyone drank water out of plastic bottles.  Today, they're as ubiquitious as the, well, plastic bag (take that and run with it Anya Hindmarch).  They've made water drinking a whole lot more convenient - if you think turning on a tap is a hassle - but also a whole lot more controversial.  Grist wrote:

"1.5 million barrels of oil go into making the bottles for the U.S. market each year, and oodles more to transporting the H2O...Advocates point out that water flows freely in nearly every U.S. home, while 38 billion recyclable plastic vessels are trashed every year." 

Even more than the waste issue, some advocates like American Jewish World Service's, Ruth Messinger, say that by bottling water "at the source" in India, Brazil, etc., as so many companies claim to do, we are actually stealing water from those people who need it most.  We have fresh tap water literally gushing out of our faucets, and still we feel the need to take it from the developing world?  That's Evil Evian.

Finally, and here's the kicker to me, plastic water bottles have turned us into wusses!  Take the marketing on the bottle of FIJI water I (admittedly, out of desperation) at a bodega the other day: "Bottled at the source, natural artesian pressure forces the water through a hermetically sealed delivery system free of human contact."

Oooh nooo! I can't have HUMAN HANDS touch my water!  I shudder just thinking about it!"  Talk about obsession with germs.  Seriously, what happened to cupping our hands and drinking straight from the rivers?  Oh yeah, they're so polluted we'd sprout a third eyeball.

Luckily Grist ended on a slightly more positive note: 

"Nestle will roll out its water brands in a bottle made of 30 percent less plastic, while Nalgene has teamed up with water-filtration giant Brita to launch a bottle-reduction campaign called FilterForGood."  Maybe this campaign will help Nalgene shed their hippie image and we'll soon see business people with caribeeners strapped to their briefcases? 

 



Leah Koenig is the Editor-in-Chief of The Jew and the Carrot: Hazon's Blog on Jews, Food, and Contemporary Life (www.jcarrot.org) She is also a freelance writer living in Brooklyn (as far as she knows, she's the


More...

Ronald


http://hubpages.com/hub/water_bottles

Now a days water bottles plays an important role in our daily life. So, select water bottles which is clean enough to drink.





Mark G


Greenpoint water

If the tap water in NYC was any good, we wouldn't feel the need to buy bottled water. I don't know how it was before bottled water appeared, but my tap water in Greenpoint is disgusting. For one thing, it's almost white in color, rather than clear. Maybe the bottled water companies are paying off the municipal water administrators to ensure that only shitty water comes out of the faucets?





François Blumen...


Well they also bottle in

Well they also bottle in glass, but people tend to prefer plastic, I guess -which is doubly stupid because it also gives a vile taste to the water. I'm not sure I see the connection with getting water from the Alps and stealing it from the third world, however. But then again I once had a cab driver explain to me that this was all bullshit -what, did I really think they flew the water in from Europe?

More seriously, although I totally appreciate your environmental concerns, the point about "what happened to cupping our hands and drinking straight from the rivers?" can only be made by someone who isn't used to the outdoors, or hasn't encountered one of Giardia, E. histolytica, Cryptosporidium, etc., etc.





Gregory C.


Yes tap water in NYC is bad...

though not as bad as what floats around here in TN, but c'mon it's very easy to install a water filter and use a refillable container.  I agree that the tapwater is repulsive, hence the use of filters. It is probably a good idea to reuse the bottles we've already accumulated (or at least the ones that don't taste like unspecified melted plastics) and have littering our car seats, etc.





Dave G


Tap water in NYC is actually good...

I don't know what kind of piping you have in your apt, but tap water in NYC is actually very clean. I've drank it...alot!

In the end of the day, we can't afford to dispose of all this plastic. That's why bottled water is being banned in NYC -- it just makes sense.





Lkoenig23


banned?

"That's why bottled water is being banned in NYC"

Really?  Since when?  Says who?  State your source man!  :)





Gregory C.


Last time I checked...

bottled water was definitely NOT being banned in NYC...