Mon, Dec 01, 2008

User login

Shvitz Search



Jewcy Book Club

This week:
and My Jesus YearDumbfounded
Welcome Authors
Benyamin Cohen
&
Matthew Rothschild
who are posting all week.
Coming up:
  • 12/08:
    Seth Greenland

Contribute


Featured Book

Featured Album



DAILY SHVITZ

Just Because You’re Infallible Doesn’t Mean You’re Always Right

François Blumenfeld-Kouchner
TAGS:
…As acknowledged by the Pope himself –oops, sorry, by his second-in-command. The whole bungle with the new-old-Latin mass may thus sort itself out by the removal of the prayer for the conversion of the Jews from the Latin missal. So while the criticism of ADL’s Foxman’s reaction to the motu proprio would certainly please most people here at Jewcy, the Catholic writer who characterized his statement as “a mix of ignorance and bellicosity” is going to have an interesting time arguing with himself: as the Pope is infallible, if he says that what he said wasn’t what he should’ve said, what should you believe?

François Blumenfeld-Kouchner

François Blumenfeld-Kouchner was born in Paris in 1978. He has been an itinerant student in France, Scotland and Ireland before reaching Chicago, where he currently lives, studies and teaches.


More...

Roger Williams


The so-called "extraordinary infallibility" of the Pope is not automatic in the Catholic church, but rather, only when he issues a command ex cathedra. The so-called "ordinary infallibility" applies under a sort of consensus decision with Catholic clergy on dogma and practices (ie, abortion is unacceptable, only celibate men may join the priesthood, et al).

When Benedict issued his statement about the Latin mass, neither condition of infallibility applied, but since he is the leader of the church, it's a good bet that the dust will be coming off a lot of the old Nova Vulgata Bibles.





François Blumenfeld-Kouchner

François Blumen...


Was hidden into a linked link, but here you go: "For this reason the Second Vatican Council states that all the Pope's teaching should be listened to and accepted, even when it is not given ex cathedra but is proposed in the ordinary exercise of his Magisterium with the manifest intention of declaring, recalling and confirming the doctrine of faith. It is a consequence of the institutional fact and spiritual inheritance that completes the dimensions of the succession to Peter."
It seems pretty clear to me.
http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/audiences/alpha/data/aud1...