Mon, Dec 01, 2008

User login

Shvitz Search



Jewcy Book Club

This week:
and My Jesus YearDumbfounded
Welcome Authors
Benyamin Cohen
&
Matthew Rothschild
who are posting all week.
Coming up:
  • 12/08:
    Seth Greenland

Contribute


Featured Book

Featured Album



DAILY SHVITZ

They Ain't Makin' Popes Like John Paul Anymore

François Blumenfeld-Kouchner

Joe ‘God’s Rottweiler’ Ratzinger, formerly of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (itself formerly the Inquisition), and formerly of the Hitler Youth, had recently changed his name to the more innocent-sounding ‘Benedict’, in the hopes no doubt of avoiding suspicions. This did not fool the more astute amongst ourselves –and indeed your most humble servant had placed a bet with a friend, to the effect that Ratzy would manage to elicit a schism part deux before the end of his reign. I must say my heart was warmed by his antics regarding his desired excommunication of all those darn Mexican legislators who recently legalised abortion. While the angelic PR team scrambled to minimise yet another papal blunder, I could only think of how closer to winning my bet His Holiness was getting me.

It was without surprise, then, that I found out this week that my pecuniary interest must take root in my apostatical, nay, heretical origin –for I, dear reader, am a Jew. And Jews, whether they believe in their mistaken religion or not, happen to be a great stumbling block for the rigorous Catholic (some would say more generally Christian) theologian: it seems we cannot reach the so-desired Judgment Day until all those mislead people finally recognise Christ as the true prophet. Hence, as long as there’ll be Jews, there won’t be a party.

And how to tell us best that we should vote for Jesus than in Latin? Liberal Catholics are already shocked, as represented by Jewcy’s own Scott Korb, who noted in his piece on the pope’s latest that “The old Latin prayer for conversion is as offensive now as when it was discarded more than thirty-five years ago.” While we can hope with Scott that this backward turn will only help eventually change the RC Church, what is the time frame going to be for this change to take place? It seems that Catholics individually act according to principles of social justiceopenness (yes, I know the limits of the reference in this last link) and modesty that are not always their hierarchy’s. But are they then still Catholics? Being a Roman Catholic seems to imply allegiance to the Pope and the Vatican: “the Second Vatican Council states that all the Pope's teaching should be listened to and accepted.” Hence the following question to my Roman Catholic friends: why not do away with an antiquated, constraining and potentially dangerous ecclesiastical hierarchy?

And just to make sure you didn’t miss on the link



François Blumenfeld-Kouchner

François Blumenfeld-Kouchner was born in Paris in 1978. He has been an itinerant student in France, Scotland and Ireland before reaching Chicago, where he currently lives, studies and teaches.


More...
François Blumenfeld-Kouchner

François Blumen...


Sorry -links have disappeared during posting; piece makes little sense without them: it's a follow up on Scott Korb's piece (http://www.jewcy.com/feature/2007-07-11/tridentine).
Please bear with me as I'm trying to put the links back up.





Anonymous


"why not do away with an antiquated, constraining and potentially dangerous ecclesiastical hierarchy?"

Because it's what keeps us from becoming a bunch of screwed-up Episcopalians whose church is falling apart. We're not doing all that badly at the moment with, I believe, about a billion members.

And your understanding of theology as requiring the conversion of the Jews before the Second Coming is incorrect. You may be confusing us with the Evangelicals. Look it up in the Catechism.

The prayer for the conversion of the Jews is no more or less than an expression of the Great Commandment: "Go therefore and make disciples of all Nations." It is not a sine qua non for the return of Jesus.





François Blumenfeld-Kouchner

François Blumen...


So success is in the numbers?
"The prayer for the conversion of the Jews is no more or less than an expression of the Great Commandment" -and the characterisation of the Jews as "perfidious" (which was suppressed in the 50's, I believe, after exactly how many years of use?) was just there because... they are?





asia kissko

asia kissko


dear Francois, I think Annon comented because he felt you wrote your post in contempt. You are not Roman Catholic if you do not acknowledge the vatican, it is in a prayer that they must recite every week in church, despite how dubious they may be at present. You both appear to have an overlapping point, RCs are going to have to relinquish what has kept them binded together since the reformation if the vatican continues in this unattractive fashion. But as one can witness when they meet Evangelists or watch televangicals or in the case of Episcos which annon mentions, the alternative aint that hot dude.