Sat, Nov 22, 2008

User login


Jewcy Book Club

Welcome Authors
Martin Samuel Cohen
&
Frances Dinkelspiel
who are posting all week.
Coming up:
  • 12/01:
    Benyamin Cohen
  • 12/01:
    Matthew Rothschild
  • 12/08:
    Seth Greenland

FAITHHACKER

Intermarriage and Jewish Grandparents

Laurel Snyder

Interfaith Grandparenting: Help Bubbe help you!Interfaith Grandparenting: Help Bubbe help you!There has been a whole lot of conversation lately about the role of the grandparents in the lives of interfaith children.  And with my own (non-Jewish) mother in town for a post-Easter/Passover visit, I'm feeling the issue in a personal way.

She called a week ago to say, "So, is Mose old enough for Peeps and Jellybeans?"  (He's not yet one and a half)

What should I have said?   "Umm... no.  Because he's only Jewish years old!" 

Instead I said, "No, both are still a choking hazard.  Why don't you just come down and we'll find him a nice treat together."  So then yesterday we got him an "Easter" milkshake, which he promptly spilled down his pants. Delightful.

But it's no small thing... the role of grandparents.  It's a very real issue, and today I wanted to offer some resources for families where this is becoming a "situation." 

Because (in the best cases of intermarriage) our generation may be creating new models for the Jewish family. We may be sitting in therapy, learning to communicate, and finding new expressions of shared ground to bridge the religious gap.  We may be setting clear boundaries. 

But our parents are... well, old.  And they're used to things being done a certain way.  And most of the time, they really do just want to help and support us... but they don't understand the lives we're constructing.  And they don't want to "intrude" a lot of the time.  But they don't know what crosses the line. 

How can they, if we don't tell them?

And then... in the worst cases, we're NOT sitting in therapy, or finding new ways. We're sticking our heads in the sand and hoping there just won't be any problems.  We're deciding that  "the kids can choose a religion when they're older" or pretending religion doesn't matter "if there's love". And our poor parents KNOW that's insane, but they don't know how to help us.

So here are some books and websites they can turn to, for help in helping us (and maybe they'd make good gifts!).  I'm sure there's more out there, and we can try to build on this, but here's a start!

Books:

Twenty Things for Jewish Grandparents of Interfaith Grandchildren to Do...

Mingled Roots: A guide...

Grandparenting Interfaith Grandchildren

Websites and articles:

Grandparenting Your Interfaith Grandkids 101

For Grandparents of Interfaith Grandkids

Grandparents Learn Strategies for Interfaith Grandkids

Interfaith Marriages Can Be Tricky for Grandparents

And there are some classes and programs too:

In New York!

In Philadelphia!

In Houston!

And elsewhere too... grandparents can find classes to help them navigate these tricky situations.

It should be said that most of the resources we've seen so far are produced by the Jewish community, for the Jewish grandparents of intermarried families.  But I think we'll see more resources soon for the non-Jewish grandparents of Jewish children too.  We've come a long way since the days when the Catholic church suggested people run out and get the babies secretly baptized, to protect their immortal souls...



Laurel Snyder

I scribble a lot. I talk too much. I apologize with wild abandon.


More...
RebeccaD

RebeccaD


You can't deprive the child of Peeps.  How do you know what religion they are?  They may have gotten sucked into the Easter industrial complex...

 





Lys H

Lys H


I like this post and especially all the information you provide, but, please, nowhere in that article does the author say that the "Catholic church suggested people run out and get the babies secretly baptized".  He says that Catholic grandparents may feel nervous and think this is something that should possibly be done in secret, based on their (mistaken) belief that the Catholic Church still believes that babies who die young without being baptised cannot go to heaven.

I certainly have a lot of problems with the RC church, but I also have a problem with wrongly ascribing blame to it...





Anonymous


What we need is for Jews to marry other Jews. Say no to intermarriage which is destroying the Jewish people.





Laurel Snyder

Laurel Snyder


I don't think I meant to say lots of people do this. I think it's something I've run into as a myth, in my work with interfaith families.  And I meant to point to a Jewish assumption that this is the case...

Sloppy on my part. Thanks for the save.

xoL http://jewishyirishy.com





Lys H

Lys H


I don't mean to be jumping all over you, it's just that I usually comment on the posts I'm interested in, so that's kind of a double-edged compliment, since I like to play Devil's advocate at the same time!  When I read the article to which you linked and was actually quite impressed by his evenhandedness (which I had not expected, naughty biased me!), I felt like I had to pipe up.





Anonymous


since my partner wasn't baptized and has no ties to organized religion, i'm pretty sure that if we ever have kids they won't be dunked in holy water either, especially since the Jewish half of this pair (me) is female.