Sat, Nov 22, 2008

User login

Shvitz Search



Jewcy Book Club

Welcome Authors
Martin Samuel Cohen
&
Frances Dinkelspiel
who are posting all week.
Coming up:
  • 12/01:
    Benyamin Cohen
  • 12/01:
    Matthew Rothschild
  • 12/08:
    Seth Greenland

Contribute


Featured Book

Featured Album



DAILY SHVITZ

Raunch Culture

Molly Crabapple

I must admit to being deeply suspicious of the “Anti-Raunch Culture” warriors. I’m reading Pornified now, but all author Pamela Paul seems to prove is that men are, gasp, masturbating. Ariel Levy’s Female Chauvinist Pigs is a bit more likable (who doesn’t want to slam Girls Gone Wild Pioneer Joe Francis, both figuratively and literally, in the gut?), but completely lacks subtlety. While Levy insists that she’s not anti-sex worker, she spends less time skewering male pornographers and more those sluts who won’t shut up.

Besides, she claims we can’t like thongs since they come from the sex industry. I wonder how Levy feels about those brothel imports- jazz and tango.

Author Tracy Quan sums up my problems with Levy and co in this Fifth Estate article.

In America, for example, the anti-raunch consensus seems to be that society is going to hell in a hand basket — and college girls are getting rowdier — because sex workers aren’t cowering in their shame-filled closets. Recalling that Vanessa Williams lost her Miss America crown because Penthouse photos had resurfaced, Ariel appears to be nostalgic for the good old days when “being exposed in porn was something you needed to come back from.” Now, to her dismay, being in porn is “itself the comeback.” Though she urges her readers to remember that sex workers are, indeed, working, you get the eerie sense that we’re like black people moving into a previously white neighborhood.

Well said.


Molly Crabapple

Molly Crabapple is a New York artist, the author of Dr. Sketchy's Official Rainy Day Colouring Book, and the founder of an art


More...
Dan Freeman

Dan Freeman


So I'll start by saying I'm a First Amendment hawk. Sounds like I'm about to shit on free speech, but give me that premise.

So here's a question i'd love to see talked about in this thread: You (and I) celebrate that "sex workers aren’t cowering in their shame-filled closets." But there's a truck that spends all day and many evenings driving around downtown New Haven, CT, where I call my humble home. It's basically a two-sided billboard on wheels, advertising "VIP" - Very Intimate Pleasures, a sex shop up the highway. A stroll to a class downtown yields at least one come-hither look from the surgically-enhanced, scantily clad woman on the side of the truck. Spices up an afternoon.

Now I'm not suggesting that the government seize the truck or that angry mothers do their covert sex-shop-shopping elsewhere. But for the partisans of free and realistic discussion of sexuality, is this what we want? Out of the closet and into ... where?  It doesn't help that the woman on teh truck isn't exactly a positive role-model for healthy body image or sexuality. And it's interesting that VIP is the only local business that advertises this way. Will this lead to acceptance of sex in daily life or a backlash?

Curious for thoughts.





Molly Crabapple

Molly Crabapple


I think tacky advertizing a feature of daily life that Target and Yahoo are just as guilty of as Dildo Shack.  As the sex industry becomes more socially acceptable, you'll see it using more of the means that other companies do to promote itself.  Am I ra ra for this?  Not really.  Big ugly ads are lame, no matter who pays for them.  But I don't think it's a problem worth existential consideration either.

 

 





Tracy Quan

Tracy Quan


Hey Molly, thanks for continuing the dialogue and hi! You're right about Ariel's barbaric treatment of American culture. Yeah, what about jazz? And ragtime?

As for thongs, they've been around for years (g-strings anyone?) and lots of times are worn for practical reasons! But Raunch Culture is a book that shows very little appreciation for cultural history -- odd, given the title.