I agree with Adam, you'll be missed, Michael. You raise some very good points here and put things in context. One major caveat. Did you really have to summon the image of Harold Bloom sleeping with Obama? Much less any one?! That's cruel!!
...band! You, Abie the Fish Man are a true believer and I think that you should join us for our World Domination Tour. We will be hitting every city with a good deli and dark alley in which to scarf our tsimmis. In fact, you've given me a new idea for a button that will simultaneously link us with our Jewish roots while paying homage (but not royalties!) to those bad boys in KISS. "KISS My Tsimmis!" Rock on Fish Man. And in case you were wondering, the password is "Swordfish".
Hey Anonymous,
Are you the same "anonymous" who sent the October 29th post about swastikas originating before the Nazis? If so, that comment, and your recent one, undermine your arguments more than they support them. I mean, come on; lots of people know that the swastika predated the Nazis, but do you really honestly believe that using it today is not intended to call the Nazis to mind? Otherwise what would be so shocking about it? You say it originated with the Greeks -- well I'm shocked, SHOCKED, to realize that the Stooges were actually trying to call to mind the ancient warriors of Sparta and the intellectuals of Athens. Who knew that they were so insidiously clever as to bypass us all with this knowledge and leave us gasping on the irony of it all in their wake?
And while we're on the subject of irony, two things: 1, it's strange that you should ask whether I've ever heard of irony when my entire discussion of Jewish punk is predicated on the idea that the punks were being ironic; and 2, it's also ironic that someone who likes to dismiss the ideas of others should hide behind a mask of anonymity rather than come out from behind the veil and speak up like a (wo)man.
Yours,
Captain Irony
Thanks for the tip about "My Last Two Thousand Years" by Herbert Gold. I'm not familiar with that one and would be especially interested to hear more about the early arc of his career. The little tidbit he offered in the interview -- about how Harpers asked him to change his name on his first published piece so that it didn't sound "so Jewish" -- bodes well for further revelations.
You might also enjoy Gold's novel "Fathers," which explores the often complicated dynamic between immigrant fathers and their "American" sons. Great stuff!
sb
Hey Tom,
Great to hear that the bartender at CBGB agrees with my book and is in fact loving it! I checked out your blog and enjoyed it immensely. If you want to check out mine, go to my website -- www.jewpunk.com -- then click on the WEB XTRAS page and you'll see the link for it under Blogga Blogga Hey.
On the eve of Genocide Celebration Day, let us all give thanks that there was once an inclusive place like CBGB.
Gobble gobble hey,
sb
PS Be sure to check out my upcoming anthology on insomnia, "AWAKE! A Reader for the Sleepless" (Soft Skull Press). In addition to award-winning writers, artists and comix creators like Charles Simic, Joyce Carol Oates, Jonathan Ames and Frank Stack, it includes contributions from punk-era sorts like Lydia Lunch, Gary Lucas, and Lynne Tillman, just to name a few.
Steven Lee Beeber will be in Washington, D.C. October 9 at the famed Black Cat club to lead a panel on the Jewish origins of punk rock, especially as they relate to the nation's capital.
The event is part of the D.C. Jewish Book Festival and will include Mark Jenkins, co-author of "Dance of Days: Two Decades of Punk in the Nation's Captial," Steve Kiviat, founder of the early '80s D.C. zine "Thrillseeker" and Lauren Strauss, a D.C.-area academic whose dissertation -- “Painting the Town Red: Jewish Visual Artists, Yiddish Culture, and Progressive Politics in New York, 1917-1939 -- is currently being turned into a book.
For more info go to Beeber's blog, "Blogga Blogga Hey!" at:
OR
http://washingtondcjcc.org/classes/center-for-the-arts/literary/litfest2007/the-heebie-jeebies-at-cbgbs.html
Hey Joel,
Thanks for your comments as well as your very interesting update on the Israeli scene. While I realize that my original post may have sounded a bit ambivalent in the end, ultimately I think what is happening in Israeli punk is mostly a good thing. Regardless of what the music sounds like (you were right when you said that I was talking about what punk represented ideologically), the fact that Israeli punks are now making the political personal – and not only for themselves, but their fellow countrymen – is a sign of positive developments for sure. I think the squatters’ movement has something of genius about it. After all, what better way to protest an illegal occupation than to stage an alternative one yourself? Squatting on land within Israel’s borders, the kids make it clear that it’s not alright to do so elsewhere – at least not if there’s already someone squatting there in the first place. How do they do this? By making the powers that be take them to court. Whether they are consciously mocking their elders with this ultimate irony is not really important – what matters, in my opinion, is the result. Not only is the issue of land rights brought up in a different context, it is detracting energy from the right wingers who see the “biblical lands” of the West Bank as theirs for the taking. Admittedly, staging such practical-joke-type stunts has the possibility of backfiring and alienating a potentially sympathetic audience, but in another sense it focuses a light on the problems as they exist. I’ve always been one for poetic solutions over political ones. You’re never going to change people’s behaviors till you change their hearts and minds. Just look at Northern Ireland. What finally brought peace? Exhaustion, that’s what. The populace was sick to death of “the troubles” and so they pressured their leaders to do something about them. Once the followers will no longer trouble themselves to stir up more unrest, things have a way of settling down. That’s why I think the new punks decision to just squat in place is most likely a good one. If the issue is one of opposing the occupation, best just to occupy a seat on the sidelines.
Yours squattily,
Steve