Sat, Oct 11, 2008

User login

Jewcy Book Club

This week:
Hyperchondriac
and
I Have Fun Everywhere I Go
Welcome Authors
Brian Frazer
 &
Mike Edison
who are posting all week.
Coming up:
  • 10/13:
    Rabbi Levi Brackman and Sam Jaffe
  • 10/20:
    Jonathan Garfinkel
  • 10/21:
    Rabbi Robert Levine
  • 10/27:
    Danit Brown
  • 10/28:
    Joshua Henkin
  • 11/04:
    Craig Glazer
  • 11/11:
    Max Gross
  • 11/17:
    Seth Greenland

Religion

Jews and Muslims Agree: No Basketball on Shabbos

by Tamar Fox, March 7, 2008

5 comments
 
TAGS:
Advertisement

The Herzl/Rocky Mountain Hebrew Academy boys basketball team in Denver qualified for the regional championship, but won’t be able to play because the game was scheduled to take place on Shabbat. The Colorado High School Activities Association governs the league the boys play in, and has refused to move the game to a time when the team could play without breaking Shabbat, claiming that rearranging the schedule on the regional level would be too complicated.
The Herzl Tigers: don't roll on shabbosThe Herzl Tigers: don't roll on shabbos
The communications coordinator for the Council on American-Islamic Relations, Amina Rubin, has come out with a statement supporting the Jewish team: “In a nation as religiously diverse as America, it is important that we all make the extra effort to accommodate the beliefs and practices of others. Student athletes should not be forced to choose between their faith and participation in sports." Several news sites chose to lead with the revolutionary idea that Muslims might support Jews in anything.

But there are some gaps in this story, like: Why is RMHA suddenly making a stink now that they’re in the finals. Why not push for a policy of no championship games on Saturdays? Why hasn’t this been an issue before now? And if, as the CHSAA claims, moving the game to late Saturday night would affect fifteen other teams and could mean more missed school time for kids on those teams, does the RMHA really have the right to demand religious accommodations?

On the other hand, incidents of anti-Semitism in Colorado are on the rise, so maybe it’s a good thing to have the Jewish community standing up for themselves.




5 comments | leave a comment
 

Ali Eteraz

03/08/08 1:42 pm
Comments: 82
Friends: 21

Joe

Wasn't Lieberman nearly Vice President while observing Shabbos? I don't particularly see why creating exemptions for those that observe it is necessary. Isn't there a principle of darura (arabic for necessity) in Orthodox Jurisprudence as there is in Islamic? A rabbi should just say "necessity requires that these boys kick ass on shabbos -- one time exception!" Why do we like to pretend that religions aren't flexible?



jewlicious

03/09/08 3:44 am
Comments: 110
Friends: 12

Kidding, right?

You're kidding right Ali? A basketball game doesn't qualify as a necessity in Jewish law - no lives are at stake. No traditional Rabbi would allow the boys to violate the Sabbath, or even possibly appear to violate the sabbath, in order to play a basketball game. 

As far as Tamar's contention that there are gaps in the story - well the RMHA didn't make a stink about the palyoff schedule because they never really ever thought they'd be in the playoffs. I find it hard to believe that the CHSAA cannot accommodate these boys and now they just look like tight-ass, obstinate douche bags. The one good thing that has come out of this is CAIR's support which is nice in light of the Jewish community's support of Muslim religious issues like the wearing of chadors, etc.

---------------------------------

I blog at Jewlicious.com



zbird

03/09/08 10:12 am
Comments: 273
Friends: 4

Rescheduling one game (this

Rescheduling one game (this particular championship) to accommodate one of the two teams that happen to be competing in it sounds totally reasonable.   And it is completely ridiculous to say it would be "too complicated" to reschedule. Sports leagues always reschedule games for weather (especially in a state like Colorado where you occasionally get 5 feet of snow in one day). 

 But saying there can be no games at all on Shabbos is ridiculous.  Then pretty soon a Christian church will not want to play on Sunday, Muslims won't play on Friday, some other religion will ban Tuesday...  There's only so many days in the week.   

--Z



Efrem "Ef" Epstein

03/09/08 4:30 pm

The CHSAA should be like The NCAA

The NCAA regularly works tournament seeding and brackets around Brigham Young University (BYU), by putting them in the Thursday-Saturday bracket so they don't have to play on Sunday.   I believe the tournament committee even has the discretion to alter a team's seed one notch in either direction for scheduling purposes.  

Are these situations equal?  I'm not sure.   But it does seem like where there's a will, there's a way and my guess is they would have put in the extra effort for a Mormon High School who wouldn't play on Sunday.



Soccer

03/10/08 7:01 pm

This brings up an interesting topic

Which is that no matter what day of the week they play on, UCLA will be this years NCAA champions, hands down!