I'm trying to understand your ethical dilemma, but frankly the profiles you made fun of previously were asking for it.

People should know that when they post stuff online, it always has the potential to be front page news (or quoted on jewcy.com)

Hey Izzy, what about the girls?

I dunno... I don't think this new approach works.  I thought your first attempt was hilarious and well-needed.  Since when is it Lamed-Hay to point out bad grammar, egotistical swagger and widely recognized bad taste?  Aside from taste which is rather subjective, neither of those are particularly Jewish values, and I think it's fair to in the very least point them out on a "Jewish" website.  We would be kidding ourselves to suggest that we haven't all looked at those profiles, and cringed or laughed.  It's with love, and I think the JDater or the week should be seen as an honor. Keep up the profile trolling...

self-promotion and braggery.  Tho

...because mine is so hidden! But at least I can still log on to check out your nominees. Maybe I'll even forward a couple to you that I find reprehensible. Ooo, that might be a bad precedent to set. Hmm.

JDate - and all of online dating - deserves all the ripping you can
humorously dish out. People put themselves out there in the most
superficial of ways and then don't expect to be superficially judged?
Maybe they've never been on a "coffee date." (I haven't!) I am out
there with the organic approach and I have been supporting my local
congregations to create singles networks so people can actually - gasp
- meet in situations that are not auditions, and maybe make
friendships? Your spotlight on JDate is something I could continue to
look forward to every week. Don't blow it!

I watch American Idol. At least the second half of the season when the talented contestants have already been chosen. The first half of the show profiles the people who audition for the show and they can roughly be broken down into three categories: Talented people who are trying to make the cut; people who do something absurd or ridiculous in order to get on to TV; and people who are picked by the producers so that they can be mocked and ridiculed on a national stage. The last category is modern television at its worst. It is cruel and malicious and caters to the basest of human emotion. In magnitude, last week's article was nowhere near as bad as American idol. Jewcy's stage is much smaller than Fox's. However, in spirit and intent, it was similar.