Tue, May 13, 2008

User login

THE CABAL
Are Armenians Angry at Jews?
TAGS:

"Thou shalt not stand against the blood of thy neighbor." — Leviticus 19:16

As editor of the Armenian Weekly, I often receive calls from journalists seeking the perspective of the Armenian community. These days, they frequently ask me whether the Anti-Defamation League is damaging relations between the Armenian and Jewish communities. My answer is always a resounding "no."

Yes, the Armenian community is upset that a prominent Jewish civil rights organization supports Turkey's campaign to the deny the Armenian Genocide, the great tragedy that haunts our community. But we are also aware of the Jewish-American writers, bloggers, and activists who speak out against ADL's hypocrisy.

Armenians also know that throughout the 20th century there was never a shortage of righteous Jews, individuals who spoke out against the Armenian genocide. Here, I present three such righteous Jews, whose efforts will always be treasured by the Armenian community.


Henry Morgenthau

From the very day when the Ottoman Turkish government started implementing the systematic destruction of the Armenians, Jewish "upstanders"—as Pulitzer Prize winning scholar Samantha Power would call them in her book A Problem from Hell—have spoken up courageously, against all odds. Take U.S. Ambassador to the Ottoman Empire Henry Morgenthau, for instance. He not only informed his government, telegram after telegram, of the horrors being committed against the Armenians, but also challenged one of the main architects of the genocide, Talaat Pasha.

 

On one occasion, Talaat told him, "Why are you so interested in the Armenians, anyway? You are a Jew; these people are Christians...We are treating the Jews here all right. What have you to complain of? Why can't you let us do with these Christians as we please?"

Morgenthau replied, "You don't seem to realize that I am not here as a Jew but as American Ambassador. My country contains something more than 97,000,000 Christians and something less than 3,000,000 Jews. So, at least in my ambassadorial capacity, I am 97 per cent Christian. But after all, that is not the point. I do not appeal to you in the name of any race or any religion, but merely as a human being. You have told me many times that you want to make Turkey a part of the modern progressive world. The way you are treating the Armenians will not help you to realize that ambition; it puts you in the class of backward, reactionary peoples."

 

Franz Werfel

Franz Werfel, an Austrian-Jewish writer, became an international literary figure with his 1933 novel, Die vierzig Tage des Musa Dagh, originally written in German and published a year later in English under the title The Forty Days of Musa Dagh. The novel tells the story of the heroic self-defense of the Armenians of Musa Dagh during the Armenian genocide of 1915.

Werfel decided to write the novel after witnessing the plight of Armenian refugee children in Damascus in 1929. Little did he know that his novel would not only become a classic and an inspiration for generations of Armenians, but would also serve as a model of survival and resistance for his own people during the Holocaust. Prof. Yair Auron writes, "The story of the defense of Musa Dagh became, indeed, a source of inspiration, an example for the underground members to learn, a model to imitate. They [the Jewish youth movements] equated their fate with that of the Armenians. In both cases, murderous evil empires conspired to uproot entire communities, to bring about their total physical extinction. In both cases, resistance embodied the concept of death and national honor on the one hand, and the chance of being saved as individuals and as a nation on the other."

 

Raphael Lemkin

Raphael Lemkin, a Polish-Jew, coined the term "genocide" in 1944 based on the planned extermination of the Armenians by the Ottoman Turks in 1915 and the Jews during World War II. He worked tirelessly to have the United Nations pass a law on the prevention and punishment of that crime. Finally, on Dec. 9, 1948, the UN General Assembly ratified the Genocide Convention. Lemkin, who lost 49 relatives during the Holocaust, wrote, "The sufferings of the Armenian men, women, and children thrown into the Euphrates River or massacred on the way to [the Syrian desert of] Der-el-Zor have prepared the way for the adoption for the Genocide Convention by the United Nations." He added, "One million Armenians died, but a law against the murder of peoples was written with the ink of their blood and the spirit of their sufferings."

***

Today, many Jewish writers and activists are walking in the footsteps of Morgenthau, Werfel and Lemkin. Time will show that it is they who are genuinely fighting against anti-Semitism, racism and bigotry. They will prove stronger than the Foxmen of this world.

NEXT: Check Jewcy's always up-to-date list of posts on the ADL/Armenian Genocide issue, or get ongoing coverage from our friends at No Place For Denial.


Khatchig Mouradian is a journalist, writer and translator. He was an editor of the Lebanese-Armenian Aztag Daily from 2000 to 2007, when he moved to Boston and became the editor of the Armenian Weekly.

His articles, interviews and poems


More...

Alamity


Armenians angry at the "few" not the "Jew"

Armenians have the utmost respect and total admiration for Jews. My sense is, that at the deepest level of clement sentiment it is virtually impossible to feel any other way.

Primarily, by the painful virtue of the Holocaust/Genocide common-denominator- experience, an Armenian and a Jew are perhaps the only metaphoric twins, conjoined right smack at the heart; a heart with a unique beat of survival against all odds. Jews and Armenians were by far the most persecuted, plundered, mass-murdered inhabitants on this planet; and yes, by far the most resilient than most! The diaspora (both, Armenian and Jewish) is a true testament of that triumphant tour de force.

In a nutshell, the title of my post really says it all: Armenians angry at the "few" not the "Jew" is an inference to a "few Foxmen" here and a "few Weaselmen" there, That's all. All decent human beings know full well, that the final phase of a genocide is denial; and an incontrovertible inspiration to genocide perpetrators yet to be born.





Levon Sassounian


Don't forget Andre Mandelstam

 One more jewish hero is

Andre Mandelstam, Ambassador of Russia in Constantinopel





Phantom


Other Notable Jews

And here are a few contemporaries that perhaps don't rise to the level of "heros", but they certainly are righteous:

Israel Charny

Yehuda Bauer

Yair Auron

Deborah Lipstadt

Robert Melson

Yosi Sarid

Yossi Beilin

Rabbi Harold Schulweis

Rabbi Edward Feinstein

Rabbi Yona Metzger

Obviously, I can go on and on.





Anoosh


Three Great Men

The true measure of the three men mentioned by Khatchig is that all three (including Mr. Lemkin) became involved in condemning the genocide of the Armenians BEFORE the Holocaust.  These great men did not speak out against the Armenian Genocide because they felt a kinship to the Armenians due to a shared history.  Rather, they spoke out against the barbarism inflicted against the Armenians because they were truly heroic and merciful individuals.  It was horribly ironic, then, when history repeated itself and the Jews were forced to suffer through unthinkable horrors less than a quarter of a century after the Armenians. 

I've always felt closest to Jews.  I don't really believe its because we share a similiar history as victims of a genocide.  Rather, I believe its because we've grown up with similiar values.  Perhaps it is because we are all a diasporan people and it is as important to the Jews to maintain their heritage and traditions as it is to the Armenians.  I'm not sure.  I do know that we have always been taught to admire the Jews and all they have accomplished both with respect to the Holocaust but also in all areas.  That is why it is so painful when individuals like Abe Foxman acts the way he does.





Post new comment

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <i> <strong> <strike> <b> <cite> <code> <u> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <p> <br> <img> <blockquote>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Images can be added to this post.

More information about formatting options

Captcha
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.