Thu, Sep 02, 2010

User login




The Kosher Guide to Imaginary Animals

Ever Wondered If Sea Monkeys Were Kosher? Wonder No More!
Jewcy Staff
 

Have you ever wondered if it's kosher to eat a dragon? What about a leviathan? A delightful new book, The Kosher Guide to Imaginary Animals, by Ann and Jeff Vandermeer, answers those questions and more. Due out in February 2010, the book is also tremendously helpful if you ever wake up and find yourself a character in a fantasy novel.

 

Editor's note: Rather than use images from the book, this gallery was made with stock images. Text, however, is excerpted from the book. 


Loading...
 
Zeevico

Zeevico


You've hit the tip of the fantasy genre's obvious Jewish potentials. A Kosher Guide to Roleplaying, The Hasidic Jew's D&D, Latkes and Lasers (the yiddishkeit sc-fi adventure game): all this and more. Just don't buy those goyishe games. Your grandmother will never forgive you.




rabbijonathan

rabbijonathan


As a long time gamer (D&D and others since 1978) and rabbi (since 1999), this is not a new topic.

One can find at least one biblical setting for a fantasy role-playing game, although I believe it is more Christian than Jewish, and as a player one can play any number of characters that would abide by rules similar to kashrut.

In one game system, called simply Mage, in a modern setting, I played a Kabbalist who also created magical effects.

I plan to attend GenCon, the mother of all game conventions this summer, in Indianapolis, (August 5-8, 2010) - let me know if you'll be there and we'll see if we can pull together a minyan!





JewBask

JewBask


It would be fun to read it on a lazy sunday afternoon, hehehe..now I wonder if the הכשר‎ of these animals would be issued by  הבד"ץ..




Mikewind Dale - Michael Makovi

Mikewind Dale - Michael Makovi


I'm not sure that dragons are non-kosher. For example, dinosaurs, being warm-blooded and having a hip-bone structure different than than of reptiles (whose bellies often drag near the ground), and sometimes even having had feathers, are closer to birds than to reptiles. The closest living relative of Tyrannosaurus Rex, for example, is the domestic chicken. So dinosaurs might very well be birds, not reptiles. If so, they'd surely be kosher, because the Torah explicitly lists all un-kosher birds, and surely the Biblical Hebrew language had no words for dinosaurs; ergo, the Torah couldn't possibly have listed them as being non-kosher. (I hear this is one of the reasons turkeys are kosher. Since they are a New World species, it was reasoned that the Torah couldn't have had prohibited them, since there was no word for "turkey" in Biblical Hebrew.)

Are dragons more like reptiles, or like birds? Are dinosaurs and dragons related or not? That is the crucial question. 





Zeevico

Zeevico


Check your facts, k thanks.

Or, my alternative response:

The discussion of dragon and dragon-esque creatures by Mike, while enlightened, proceeds upon the premise that the Torah is to be interpreted literally in terms of the birds it states to be unkosher; yet I would query whether a literalist interpretation of the Torah is valid in all circumstances and hence, whether a literalist interpretation is valid in this circumstance in particular. A consistent interpretative approach to any text or (Jewish) legal stricture is a necessary ingredient of the rule of (Jewish) law. In other words pick an interpretive approach to the text first,  justify your choice, and then go on to discuss its application to the present circumstances.

K thanks. 





tiskus


like dragons).