Thu, Aug 21, 2008

User login

FAITHHACKER
Your Greatest Stumbling Block

I’m creating an SIQ-test. It stands for “Spiritual IQ”. So far, I've only written one question:

What was the greatest impediment to Jewish spirituality in all of history?

A. Idolatry
B. The destruction of the Temple
C. Persecutions
D. False messiahs
E. Economic prosperity
F. None of the above

What do you say? I vote for F, none of the above.

This is because I believe that the greatest stumbling block to Jewish spirituality in all of Jewish history was...

A guy named Michelangelo.

Well, it wasn’t really him as much as something he created: Michelangelo gave us (quite literally!) a cartoon image of God. Do you know what I’m talking about? The Sistine Chapel image of God creating Adam? God is depicted as an old man with a long white beard:

So for the past 500 years we have been saddled with this cartoon image, and the word “God” has become for many associated with the old man and long white beard.

If you think about it, though, didn’t Michelangelo have a point? After all, it says in Genesis that God made Man in His image....So doesn’t that mean that God looks like us?

Well, no.

The God that Jews have always imagined is an Infinite, unknowable...something. I don’t even want to say “being” because the word “being” like any word, begins to define or limit God and we’re talking about something that is non-definable, not finite, a.k.a., infinite.

So, when Moses asks to see God in Exodus 13, God says, “No one can see my face and live” - this limit of human perception is consistent with an Infinite God.

A close reading of Genesis leads to an even deeper idea about God. Genesis describes humanity as made “in the image of God”. So according to the Torah, it is we who have God’s characteristics, not the other way around. Yes, God has a “hand”, but our hand is only an image of that. We don’t know what God’s “hand” looks like because our entire perception is trapped within the framework of this physical realm, and God is transcendent.

Therefore, the only way for us to glimpse what is meant by God’s hand is via some kind of transcendental technique, such as meditation. That’s what Micah and Isaiah and other sages were doing when they glimpsed God. But they weren’t seeing God’s essence, only a spiritual projection that is more subtle than this finite world (which is also a projection) but not God’s true essence, which is likened to seeing God’s face.

In other words, God isn't anthropomophic. We are theomorphic.

I’ll end these holy thoughts with two tools, one practical and one amusing.

The practical tool is a superb on-line test you can take at beliefnet.com to determine your religious affinity. It is remarkably well-designed; someone put a lot of thought into it. Here’s the online test. After you take it, please share your results in the comments section below. My own results were a surprise, which I'll share after a few other people get a chance to comment.

The amusing tool is this video series on youtube – the later episodes are not quite Jewish, but the first one (below) is universal. If you subscribe to my Friday Table Talk blog then you saw this already.

Roll over Michelangelo. The God of the 21st Century wears black-rim frames and sports a goatee.

Tomorrow: What’s a mitzvah and what difference does it make?



Rabbi Alexander Seinfeld graduated from Stanford University with degrees in Classics and Anthropology. Having exploring numerous traditions, he began his return toward a Jewish path after living in rural Mississippi, “surrounded by folks


More...

myshkin


99 names of God

I wonder if Islam, which, so far as I know, tries extra hard to avoid anthropomorphizing God, might be helpful here. Yes, I know you can find pretty much the same thing in Jewish texts--but this is so clear, so direct, so frontal--The 99 Beautiful Names of God. (Perhaps attributes might be a better term.)

http://www.sufism.org/society/asma/





JewcyCraig


My results

That was fun. My top five results:

1. Unitarian Universalism (100%) 2. Secular Humanism (98%) 3. Liberal Quakers (90%) 4. Neo-Pagan (83%) 5. Theravada Buddhism (77%)

 





Uriah


Refrom AND Orthodox?

1. Reform Judaism (100%) 2. Orthodox Judaism (83%) 3. Bahá'í Faith (82%) 4. Sikhism (81%) 5. Islam (78%) 6. Liberal Quakers (76%) 7. Mainline to Liberal Christian Protestants (72%) 8. Unitarian Universalism (71%) 9. Neo-Pagan (60%) 10. Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints (Mormons) (55%) 

Never thought someone would say I fit 55% of Mormon beliefs. 





François Blumen...


Ahahahahah

1. Secular Humanism (100%)2. Unitarian Universalism (92%)3. Nontheist (76%)4. Liberal Quakers (74%)5. Theravada Buddhism (71%)6. Neo-Pagan (68%)
Glad to see I'm a neo-pagan too, just like Craig!





JewcyCraig


Neo-Pagan

We must've had some very similar answers, Francois!





François Blumen...


Yeah, I find that profoundly

Yeah, I find that profoundly disturbing. Does that mean I'll grow huge square sunglasses too? ;-)





Joey Kurtzman


You talking to me?

"God says, 'No one can see my face and live'” Hashem is such a badass!

1. Secular Humanism (100%) 2. Unitarian Universalism (94%) 3. Nontheist (82%) 4. Theravada Buddhism (82%) 5. Liberal Quakers (80%)





Shaina


Nice to know

Here are my top 5 answers:

1. Orthodox Judaism (100%)
2. Islam (95%)
3. Sikhism (94%)
4. Reform Judaism (89%)
5. Bahá'í Faith (85%)

As I am an orthodox Jew, it was nice to see that my answers agree with my belief. But I must admit, the fact that it also is close with Islam and Sikhism makes me question...





JewcyCraig


Not surprising

I believe the premises of both religions are very similar, Shaina. It's only when nutsjobs take one (or the other) to an extreme that it becomes a problem..

And Francois! How could you!? You mentioned my deformity so openly in such a public forum! Of course you won't grow huge square sunglasses. I WAS BORN THIS WAY. It's not like it's contagious - like being a French expatriot...





Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <i> <strong> <strike> <b> <cite> <code> <u> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <p> <br> <img> <blockquote>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Images can be added to this post.

More information about formatting options

Captcha
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.