Fri, Jul 25, 2008

User login

FAITHHACKER
No Tears for Jerry

So as we all know, Jerry Falwell (founder of the so-called Moral Majority)  is dead, and this JTA article discusses the mixed feeling Jews had about the man.

Statements from Jewish leaders about his death were duly respectful of a man who loved Israel, but were qualified also by his embrace of values that alienated most American Jews.

This is something I will never never understand.  How thinking Jewish people can in any way stand behind someone like this.  How Israel, or any other single issue, can be important enough to trump our other concerns. Like not getting into bed with racist homophobic misogynists.

Here's a lovely quote from Mort Klein (leader of the Zionist Organization of America):

"Jews should have appreciated his virtually unconditional support more than we did," Klein said. "We should also have appreciated that his deep support for Israel came from strong belief in the Torah, in the Bible."

Okay... NO!  the support of evangelical Christianity for Israel does NOT come from a strong belief in the Torah.  It comes from a strong belief in the Christian Bible, which condemns us to Hell and views Israel as a necesary ingredient in the ultimate destruction of all us heathens.  If the 5 books of Moses happen to be a re-translated part of the book, so what?  That fact, and our shared interest in Israel does NOT make for a Judeo-Christian America.  Does not make us friends.

I feel strongly that my (not so clean and happy) neighborhood should be a clean and happy place.  The  awful investor who owns the vacant house next to mine, and wants to flip it for profit, feels strongly that this neighborhood needs to "transition faster" too.  But why we feel these things, and how we live our lives sets us apart. And no shared desire for a coffee shop around the corner will make us friends.

Jerry Falwell is dead. And while I don't rejoice in anyone's death, I can't mourn this man.  He thought that the antichrist (ANTICHRIST) was a Jewish man.  He thought AIDS was "the wrath of a just God". 

He liked Israel.  He stood for pretty much everything I hate.  He died.

RIP

 

 



I scribble a lot. I talk too much. I apologize with wild abandon.


More...

Monica Osborne


I agree with you, Laurel,

I agree with you, Laurel, especially when it comes to not getting into bed with "racist homophobic misogynists" like Falwell and his cronies.

But this is a bit more complicated than it appears:

Okay... NO!  the support of evangelical Christianity for Israel does NOT come from a strong belief in the Torah.  It comes from a strong belief in the Christian Bible, which condemns us to Hell and views Israel as a necesary ingredient in the ultimate destruction of all us heathens.  If the 5 books of Moses happen to be a re-translated part of the book, so what?  That fact, and our shared interest in Israel does NOT make for a Judeo-Christian America.  Does not make us friends.

While I think that Klein is nuts to suggest that Jews should've appreciated Falwell's support of Israel more than we did, I think the part about his support coming from a strong belief "in theTorah, in the bible" is a bit more complicated than it sounds. For Falwell and many Evangelicals like him, the entire Hebrew bible (Old Testament, which is obviously problematic on so many levels), and not just the Christian New Testament, also provides the basis for this creepy kind of unwavering support for Israel. The problem, for me, is not so much what's in the "Christian bible," but the way they read the Hebrew bible in conjunction with it -- apocalyptically, and as literalists. I guess the point I'm trying to make is that if we conceive of Torah not only as the five books of Moses but also as the whole Hebrew bible, Talmud, and Midrash, Klein actually has a point. The problem, however, is that he's privileging any form of belief in the bible/Torah (no matter how crazy the reading is) over appropriate interpretations of Torah. In other words: We don't care how you interpret Torah as long as you believe in it.

And that, it seems to me, is the biggest problem here.





Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <i> <strong> <strike> <b> <cite> <code> <u> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <p> <br> <img> <blockquote>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Images can be added to this post.

More information about formatting options

Captcha
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.