| Comment of the Week: Big Business vs. Big Jesus | |
|
by Tamar Fox, November 29, 2007
|
|
This week we salute Uriah’s comment on the Megachuch and taxes post.
If these megachurches are making money from shopping malls, movie theatres, and sporting events, and not having to pay taxes, then the separation of church and state has gone too far. How much of that money is actually being used for something other than cushioning the pockets of Elders, Deacons, and Reverends?
Big Butter Jesus: totally treyf
And, no, I wouldn't shop at a place I knew was owned by a Christian religious organization. I also wouldn't patronize anyplace I knew had anything along the lines of sweatshops involved in the making of their products.
Big business is big business, not big jesus. If I'm not running around my restaurant with my Tanakh under my arm proclaiming jesus as a heretic and a fake, they shouldn't be running around the movie theatre shouting about jesus as the true creator. It's ridiculous.
But actually, all of the comments made on that post were really interesting and provocative, so I salute everyone who threw in their two cents. This has the potential to become a really big problem both for the government, and for Jews who are trying to decide where to shop and spend time. The discussion in the comments is exactly why I love Jewcy—varied and intelligent and didn’t involve anyone making comments about me and my cuntocracy.
Too many of you readers aren’t commentators. And I know you’re smart. Show me some lip, people.
![]() |
Tamar Fox has an MFA from Vanderbilt University in Nashville, but she still doesn't like sweet tea. Born and raised in Chicago, she's also lived in Iowa City, Dublin, Oxford, and Jerusalem. When she's not rocking out at honky tonks she teaches More... |
Raichu
Neither church nor
Neither church nor synagogue is supposed to operate as a business, and what of megachurches with built-in McDonald's and the like? Yashua knocked down stands changing money and selling animals for sacrifice when he found them at temple. In fact, it's documented that he does this twice. Christianity is supposed to be an emulation of Yashua's life, so the existence of business churches should be a sign that in contemporary Christianity, there's something lacking.
It's a treat to find a Christian who keeps the Shabbat on the correct day, and keeps the Levitical food laws.
Jonathan
They're supposed to be paying taxes....
"If these megachurches are making money from shopping malls, movie theatres, and sporting events, and not having to pay taxes, then the separation of church and state has gone too far."
Absolutely true, except that under US IRS regulations, any income derived from non-religious purposes (including shopping malls, movie theaters, and sporting events) is taxable, and the law is pretty clear on that. The only real problem is that in some cases, it's a little hard to separate out religious sourced income from non-religious sourced income. It might be hard for the IRS auditors to figure out the church leased some room to a public group to hold a secular meeting (a taxable event), but it's not really hard for them to find the revenue from the lease payments for the strip shopping mall built on their land down the street. The IRS has started looking, and they are finding it. Obviously, the churches aren't happy, but if they don't pay those taxes, they can (and in some recent cases, they have) lost their tax exempt status.
Peace Love Unity
We need to be fearful of
We need to be fearful of over-generalization, 'cause honestly it can spread like the black plague.
If some of the Christian Churches are doing what it stated above, then they need to be dealt with properly. It is plainly wrong!
As far as where you spend your money, well if I knew a worship place is misspending my mullah, then yeah I would not even donate my mullah or buy anything. And if I strictly lived by the rule of knowing where my $ is going, then I have to investigate every store before shopping there and not places just Churches, as in my eyes this can create discrimination and misrepresentation.
I tell you this, I know of many other worship places that do the same. And I wish, this article next time the article compares worship places and not a Church vs. Sweatshop (as there are many differences between those two).
Regards,
PLU
Post new comment