Nice response, Joey.  You hit that one out of the ballpark.

They say Bob Dylan was the "voice of a generation."
I really believe you've just voiced the essential worldview of my generation of Jews.

Of course, I wouldn't be Jewish if I didn't have at least a small caveat:

You dispute Wertheimer's notion of a generation with a "fractured identity" by saying that "We’re confident in who we are, we feel excited and privileged to live in such a singular time, to have received so unprecedented and exceptional a heritage."

I think you both could be right here. I have no doubt you and your friends are as you describe them, and I think I can describe myself the same (at least in my better moments).

Still, I think the very freedom we enjoy in a post-modern culture, where every aspect of our lives is up for grabs, makes it inevitable that our identity is somewhat fractured. For example, I too reject Wertheimer's ethnocentricity, but nevertheless I can't help feeling queasy at the thought that a future shiksha wife might want to baptize my kids. There's definitely a fracture of some sort between my idealistic worldview and my lower tribal instincts.

I think we can label this "fracture" as something more positive--like being inquisitive, or wrestling with G-d ("Israel" in Hebrew). But our identity is definitely split.

so many americans are desperately searching for identity and meaning, and a true sense of home, as the centrifugal and atomizing forces of modern consumerism and the collapse of other ideologies leave people adrift, alienated, homeless.

So people either flounder in the world of instant gratification, or they seek meaning in meditation, cults, or religion... american indians increasingly move back to the reservation and to their homeland, away from the cities of alienation, even though they face daunting poverty.

so too with that most alienated of people, the Jews.  We have, tailor-made for us, a wisdom tradition specifically designed to fix a people from the brokennesses of enslavement, colonization, and exile.  and even more remarkable, we've won most of our homeland back!!

 My activism for anarchist and AmerIndian land-rights issues is what led me to israel, eventually; indians asked my friend and i, aren't you jewish? didn't you win your land back? don't you know that that's all we want?  what are you doing here talking to us?

  Look, america is trying to finish off the ethnocentric cult: this is the mission, the crusade, of the ideologies at the heart of the west.  But it's an ideology of emptiness, of relativism, of homelessness, of denial.  Jews in America have a choice: assimilate and seek the future of their human potentials in the bewildering and challenging emptiness of the american ideological world.  Or come home-- to israel, for real, to the land, not to a shul in brooklyn or lakewood.  Jewish life in america will not sustain.  but in the long run, an ideology of emptiness will not sustain either.  come home.  and if you don't like israel the way it is, don't bitch about it, come here to help change it into something worthy of our ideals.

A good response, but I agree with mmausner above that "Jewish life in america will not sustain" -- it's only a temporary haven...in the long run the only way is in Israel. Jews are a fractured, broken, homeless, and alienated people, and the ONLY way to begin to repair the wound is to end the exile and return home to Israel.

In America, it's not acceptable to be "ethnically aware" as traditional Judaism supposes its members should be..."White power" and White ethnocentrism largely died out by the 1950s, Black power only lasted about a decade (the 1970s), Mexican nationalism ("La Raza") is rather marginal at best, and thus Jewish ethnocentrism isn't acceptable either. Jewish nationalism ("Zionism") is also rather suspect in America because of accusations of dual loyalty.

In America, ALL are equal before the Constitution ("All [humans] are created equal"), whether White, Black, Jew, or Gentile. This is diamentrically opposed to The Old World (Europe, et al), but in The New World 'Brazilification' is the norm, i.e. we are all just a huge mish-mash of widely differing cultures, races, religions, and so forth, and we all marry and breed with whoever we like/love the most regardless of race/ethnicty, religion, or culture.

Believe it or not, most Jews I've talked to about the subject all say that strict Jewish intermarriage and separation from the so called 'unclean' Gentiles provokes anti-Semitism, just like what happened in pre-WWII Europe...Jews obsessed with "blood purity," totally separated/alienated from the Gentile community (remember: it is THEIR country and Jews are/were merely a 'guest minority'), and so forth. All of this is shattered in The Americas because these places don't belong to any single ethnic or religious group, unlike Europe, the Middle East, Africa, Asia, and so forth.

If a White European wanted to be a White nationalist I'd tell him to return to Ireland or Norway or whatever, and if an African-American was a Black nationalist I'd say he should buy a plane ticket back to the Africa. Same with Jews...if Jews want to be ethnocentric and clannish, Israel is there waiting for you. However, the paranoid, cut off, and highly ethnocentric tendencies of strict diaspora Judaism only deepen the wounds of an already wounded people.

And remember: nearly all of the most revered and accomplished Jews in history were/are "apostates."

Only a fucking anti-semite would say that Jews are to blame for anti-semitism and the Holocaust. Mishling is saying that anti-semitism will cease when the Jews stop being Jews and become like the rest of the world.
This has some kind of logic because then there would be no more Jews to hate which is what Nazis like Mishling want. What a fucking asshole!
Perserving the Jewish people is not clannish or racist. ITS SURVIVAL! Only anti-semites and Nazis can't see the differnce.

Mischling said that certain Jewish traits cause antisemitism (extreme ethnocentrism, xenophobia, fanatical separation/Jewish ghettoization, considering Gentiles 'unclean')...don't distort his/her words.

Joey is right when he says that Judaism is finished in America. My influence is apparent in creating self-hating Jews like Joey. My philosophy of Aryan superority is being embraced by Joey and other Jews. That means less Jewish children and less Jews.

Your ancestors must be so proud that you are married to a shiksa and worship Gentiles. You are a good Nazi Jew. Heil Seil Joey! You make an old Nazi like me proud. Most Jews in the world hate being Jewish and are marrying Goys which is a proud achievement of my legacy.

Thanks for making my dream of a Judenfree world come true. America will be soon be Judenfree. What a celebration that day will be for all us Nazi and Jew-haters, right Joey? Israel will disappear soon and then there will be no more Jews. My goal will be achieved soon with the help of all you Kapos. I will make all of you honoray SS members.

I would have never murdered millions of Jews if they weren't so Jewish. If they had assimilated, intermarried and become Gentiles, I wouldn't have had to kill them. Most people who read this blog understand this. The Jews are to blame for the Holocaust, the pograms, and all the anti-semitism because they refused to conform to what the world finds acceptable. It's good that Jews today understand this and are doing their best to become Gentiles and have perfect Goy children.

I love this blog because it makes me so proud of creating such self-hating, Goy worshipping Kapo Jews. Keep up the good work my fellow Nazis! Heil Hitler! Heil Hitler! Through your actions you have murdered millions, a second Holocaust, of Jewish people and I love you for it.

Wow! Hitler! I thought you were dead! Where were you??

This is actually a magazine article, though. Not a blog. 

My favorite parts were when he said "Heil Seil Joey" and "Goy-worshipping Kapo Joe"! In general, the more times I hear "Intermarriage is like Hitler!" the more persuasive I find it.

If nothing else, Jewcy's forum has definitely satisfied Godwin's law: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_law

We get a lot of good discussion as well. Alas, such is life on the internetz, and particularly on a Jewish website, that even the most compelling conversation will be punctuated by random shout-downs about somebody being just like Hitler.

Please create a profile so we can befriend you and you can post events 'n shit.

Joey, like a good Nazi, supports intermarriage. Good for you! We both want a Judenfree world and we will get our wish soon. I thnk it's great that you have a sense of humour about destruction of the Jewish people. I also laughed when I was throwing Jews into the gas chambers. Ha! Ha! It will be especially funny when there are no more Jews left.
You probably shout. "Heil Hitler" "Heil Hitler" when you screw your ugly shiksa wife. Gentiles are so much better than the dirty low-life Jews. Thanks for making the Jews irrevalent and extinct.
I will make a profile soon because I have a lot of followers here in this great anti-semitic Nazi-loving blog. Keep up the good work in promoting the genocide of the killing the Jewish people. Heil Seil!

"Heil Seil!"

Hail the rope? Perhaps you mean "Sieg Heil," as in "Hail victory." Your trolling posts just lack that extra effort that's necessary for offensive authenticity. I'm disappointed in you.

I did my BA in History at Yale on the museum that the Nazis were building to memorialize the Jews, in Prague, so this happens to be a subject I'm somewhat expert in...  The Nazis were absolutely right about certain aspects of Jewish identity.  They recognized that maintaining Jewish identity in the face of modern nationalism created an inevitable conflict of interest; they recognized that Jewish identity in general, praying to Jerusalem, created a situation where the 'locals' wherever they were would mistrust Jews because Jews weren't truly invested in the land and permanence in those places. 

And most odd, the Nazis recognized Jewish morality was genuinely opposed to the Aryan morality they espoused, and when they were building the museum, they brought Jews to create the dioramas of Jewish life-cycle events-- and didn't even edit!! they just thought it would be self-evident that the Jews' life-affirming morality would be seen as a 'slave' morality by the new Germans, even without captions!!

The Nazis were right about many things.  They were just wrong about many MORE things, including insane, apocalyptic racism, genocide, and a few more quirks.

A couple of years ago I went into a Jewish bookstore in Silver
Spring MD - just to browse (at that time- I was interested in Avraham
Abulafia)- and when the owner of the store took one look at me - I
could tell he was somehow upset by my presence - (even though
I could probably pass for a Sephardic Jew)....something about his body
language froze up. Later - as I went to the cash register to pay (his wife or daugter was there) and sensing her discomfort (she seemed to back away) - I put the money down on the counter. Then she extended one arm - without
getting one millimeter closer ot the counter- and grabbed the money. I was wondering when she was going to pull out one of those gadgets people
use to pick up trash on the street.....the one with the 6-ft. extension.

Lacking any valid new arguments against Hitler's posting, I would just like to point out his use of the word "irrevalent" gave me the impression that Hitler might actually be a cartoon dog created by the Hanna-Barbara Corporation. I wanna hear him say he's having "pasghetti and mamatoes" for dinner.

I thought Hitler was dead?

Oh dear God..!