| When Love Becomes Hate | |
|
by Beth Gottfried, January 17, 2007
|
|
Germany is asking the European Union to ban the display of swastikas, claiming that it's a "crime to deny genocide." Having a close Indian friend and understanding the sanctity of the symbol in the Hindu religion where it translates in Sanskrit to may goodness prevail and is used as a sign of peace, I'm torn with Germany's proposition.
Germany, alarmed by a rise in far-right crime, wants to harmonize the rules for punishing offenders in member states.
"In Germany the fight against racism and xenophobia is both an historic duty and a current political concern," Germany's Justice Ministry said, laying out its plans earlier this month.
Kallidai said Germany's initiative was probably well-meaning but there had been no consultations.
"Every time we see a swastika symbol in a Jewish cemetery, that of course must be condemned. But when the symbol is used in a Hindu wedding, people should learn to respect that," he told Reuters.
In my heart, I disagree with this call because it serves to diminish all that is holy in one culture for the sake of succumbing to the xenophobia of another. On the other hand, I think Germany is responding a greater threat of evil and that the action serves to show that they won't stand for hate crimes and that Europe needs to be on board with them. And unfortunately, what the image evokes in today's Western culture is that of hatred and intolerance.
![]() |
Beth Gottfried Lisogorsky is a professional blogger whose work has appeared on numerous sites from Rotten Tomatoes to PopMatters. She loves film, TV (yes "the boob tube"), and music and has critiqued on all three. In 2004, she published a book More... |
cshefman
The solution isn't too
The solution isn't too complicated, and I'd imagine would be included in any final proposal. Essentially do the same thing done in Canada with Gay marriage. A religion exemption.
Something like;
1. The swastika is hereby banned from use in any public place.
2. Section 1 shall not apply to any Hindu religious institution.
Or something of that sort.... I absolutely support the ban, as long as protection is made so Hindu's can continue to enjoy their religion to the fullest extent possible.
Michael Nehora
Excellent suggestion, cshefman
After all, Hindus shouldn't be penalized for someone else's perversion of their religious symbol.
Indeed, the swastika, long before the Nazis ruined it for everyone, was a standard religious or decorative symbol in many cultures around the world, such as non-Hindu Eastern religions and Native American societies. Even the Ein Gedi synagogue, of the Roman era, featured swastikas on its floor. It is, after all, an easy shape to come up with, like the spiral, pentagram, hexagram (our magen david), and the various types of cross.