Fri, Sep 05, 2008

User login

DAILY SHVITZ
'Gossip Girl' Season Finale Shocker: Still No Jews!
Some fans are bummed that Josh Schwartz's CW hit lacks a Seth Cohen

Serena van der Woodsen and Dan Humphrey, sittin' in a tree: She loves him despite their minimal differences!Serena van der Woodsen and Dan Humphrey, sittin' in a tree: She loves him despite their minimal differences!

 

 

Tonight's finale of the strike-shortened first season of 'Gossip Girl', the buzzed-about CW show based on the ubersuccessful series of young adult novels about the lives of rich Manhattan private school kids, promises to be a doozy. Will Blair Waldorf's life of privileged partying come screeching to a halt when she finds herself knocked up? Is the putative baby's daddy bad boy Chuck Bass or floppy-haired Nate Archibald? Will Lily van der Woodsen sacrifice her daughter Serena's happiness to pursue her fated luv with Serena's Williamsburg-bred boyfriend Dan Humphrey's improbably youthful dad Rufus? Did the actress who plays Serena really get a nose job right before the series started filming? (Well, yes.)

 

Some or all of those questions might get answered on tonight's show, but this one probably won't: what is up with the show's insistence that almost everyone in its purview, including those downtrodden Humphreys (they have to live in Brooklyn!) is so incredibly WASPy?

Okay, that's a slight exaggeration. After all, much has been made of the show's inclusion of two mostly-mute characters who fans have unceremoniously dubbed Black Girl and Asian Girl. And of course there's Dan's alternative love interest Vanessa Abrams, who lives on the Lower East Side and is sort of brownish. But as writer Jonathan Liu puts it, it's the dearth of Jews among the students at Constance Billiard which makes the show's portrayal of the scions of Manhattan's ruling class (even) less believable: "I doubt that an all-WASP elite actually exists anywhere anymore." Times magazine interview-lady Deborah Solomon even specifically took the show's creator Josh Schwartz to task about this, quizzing him, "Why are the characters uniformly white, with old-money names like Blair Waldorf and Serena van der Woodsen that hark back to a time when high society was not integrated? Why are there no Jewish characters?"

"It’s interesting, because on 'The O.C.' I went out of my way to make those characters Jewish, not what you would expect to find in Orange County. But in New York, weirdly, I failed. I was working off of the source material," Josh explained. Well, fair enough (though the show does diverge from the books in a million other ways). If that excuse doesn't work for you, you can always go with Meghan McArdle's explanation for the show's "anasemitic" quality: "Media executives are leery of portraying rich New York day schools, or the entertainment industry, as being chock full of Jewish people for fear of encouraging the stereotype that Jews control all the media and the money in this country." Hmm!

Of course, a huge part of GG's addictive charm lies in the fact that it in no way resembles present-day New York -- the prep school fantasyland it depicts seems almost to be set the 60s, but with cel phones. For me, at least, this is what makes the show such an escapist pleasure. But even if just for superficial reasons, some of the show's fans mourn the Semitic sex appeal of Schwartz's last hit. Musing about the charms of Dan Humphrey, a gal of my acquaintance sighed: "Well, he's no Seth Cohen."



Emily Gould is a writer who lives in Brooklyn.


More...

nicolebeth


lack of Jews in Gossip Girl...

At least Lily van der Woodsen had a funny and acknowledging-of-reality-if-a-stereotype comment about Chinese food and Jews and Christmas...

Though, I agree that it doesn't make sense.  How about the annoying Vanessa, though?  Her name is Abrams.  She's "artsy" and "edgy".  Is she supposed to represent the Jews?  I hope not, as I find her character really annoying.

 We are kind of expecting a lot of Josh Schwartz, though, to carry the torch for all Jews everywhere.  How many shows have portrayals of Jews that are good?

 I do enjoy watching this "WASP"-view-of-the-world, however dated it might be--it's definitely my favorite new show.





Maayan


Private schools With NO Jews?

Sad as it is I have become reeled into this show and find myself watching it every week, despite the teenage drama at it's worse. But the fact that this prep school in New York City does lack Jews surprises me. Are there even any private schools anymore without Jews in them? But if he wants the WASP crowd, there are plenty of views who can relate to it.

All in all, I still enjoy the show.

 





RL


Who cares! Still,

""Media executives are leery of portraying rich New York day schools, or the entertainment industry, as being chock full of Jewish people for fear of encouraging the stereotype that Jews control all the media and the money in this country." Hmm!"

This kind of thinking, btw, is a sign  of pc cultural thinking!





Perlman


Seth Cohen is A Myth

I went to Orange County...there are no Jews there so maybe it's the creator's way of flipping the locale stereotypes, what's next? a show about black people in Iowa....whassup wit dat?





Anonymous


a few are still old line waspy.. Buckley

supposedly Buckley and a few others are still pretty Jew-less. But overall yeah, pretty stupid





Dweeb


Best Christmakkuh present ever

What a great surprise!  I hope this becomes a weekly feature.

And, the underrepresentation of Jews only serves to make it that much more dramatic when Jenny converts so that she can marry her divorce attorney and adopt that Chinese baby.





Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Use <!--pagebreak--> to create page breaks.
  • HTML tags will be transformed to conform to HTML standards.
  • Images can be added to this post.

More information about formatting options

Captcha
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.