Fri, Nov 21, 2008

User login

Shvitz Search



Jewcy Book Club

Welcome Authors
Martin Samuel Cohen
&
Frances Dinkelspiel
who are posting all week.
Coming up:
  • 12/01:
    Benyamin Cohen
  • 12/01:
    Matthew Rothschild
  • 12/08:
    Seth Greenland

Contribute


Featured Book

Featured Album



DAILY SHVITZ

Asian Persuasion: Lost Tribes of Israel Found in Japan?

Helen Jupiter
TAGS:

Utter Blasphemy: or ancient history?Utter Blasphemy: or ancient history? Certain members of my extended family have what my mother affectionately refers to as, "the almond shaped eyes." Their features are so distinctive that they are often mistaken as Asian. People are always surprised to learn that no, they're not Asian at all--in fact, they're Jewish. My mother, ham that she is, laughs it all off with the explanation that, "somewhere along the way, someone must have hooked up with an Asian person." It's funny to imagine a freethinking (read: horny) ancestor of ours with a penchant for lovers of the Asian persuasion, but perhaps there's more to this bedtime story. A few months ago I stumbled upon this YouTube video, which depicts an annual Japanese pilgrimage to Israel:

In and of itself, I find the video to be mind-boggling, amusing, touching, and bizarre. Japanese Jews in Israel, marching down Ben Yehuda street in kimonos, waving Japanese and Israeli flags and singing "Hevenu Shalom Aleichem." Does it get any weirder than that? Well, yes--perhaps it does.

Recently, a couple of fascinating posts about a certain lost tribe (or two, or ten) have appeared on the ol' Internets. The knowledge of a Jewish migration into Asia is nothing new, but these particular posts purport that the Japanese are actually a part of the Lost Tribes of Israel. Published in response to an episode of Nippon TV’s Mino Monta's Japanese Mystery, they present research that has drawn mysterious parallels between Japanese and Jewish history and culture. You can watch some of the clips from the show here.

Israeli officials publicly acknowledge the mysterious similarities between Judaism and Japan. Recently, in March of 2007, Rabbi Avichail of the Israeli Investigative Body Amishav, which searches for descendants of the Lost Tribes, arrived in Japan. Although they only stayed for a short amount of time, the investigative body concluded that “There is no doubt that there is some kind of strong connection between Judaism and Japan. More research is needed to determine the details.”

The connections are very interesting.

For example, the Japanese Shintoist Holy day of July 17th is the Yamaboko Junko, or “Going atop the Mountain to lay to rest the Shrine”. In the old testament, July 17th is the day Noah’s Ark rested atop Mount Ararat. The word “Essa”, which is a carrying chant chanted by the holders of the Omikoshi, or portable shrine, is a word which really has no meaning in Japanese but means “Carry” in Hebrew.

One of Japan’s largest festivals, the Gion Festival, is believed by many, including the Gion Festival officials, to be the same as Ancient Israel’s Zion Festival. The month long festival is almost identical in each event, date, etc. The artwork depicted on the portable shrines in the festival are from ancient Japan, but are renderings of landscapes in the middle east - camels walking the desert, pyramids, Baghdad Palaces, and most surprising is a grand picture of Rebecca offering water to Isaac which is confirmed to be a rendition of Genesis 24 in the Old Testament.

Also explored are some striking similarities between the Japanese and Hebrew languages. Allegedly, there are about 500 Hebrew and Japanese words that are nearly identical, including Kaku (to write), Toru (to pick something up), and Hakushu (to clap). Whether these linguistic similarities are merely coincidental remains to be seen.

The idea that the ancient, immigrant Hata clan, which was active during the Yamato period (disputed dates range from 250 - 710 A.D.), were among the Lost Tribes of Israel is not widely accepted, but it does have its champions. A number of scholars have recognized this theory, and it's a central tenet of certain Japanese "New Religions" (although doctrines based largely on The Protocols of the Elders of Zion discredit some of them entirely).

It's not far-fetched to imagine ancient Jews traveling east from Asia Minor and winding up in Japan, but who they were, when they arrived, how deep they lay their roots, and the legacy they left behind has yet to be determined.



Helen Jupiter

Helen Jupiter is a writer based in Los Angeles. In the past she has contributed to Gridskipper


More...

Anonymous


Some comments on the Youtube page (and what a motley assortment of love and hate we have there!) would seem to indicate that these people may not be Japanese Jews, but rather Makuya -- a strongly-Zionist Christian sect.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Makuya

 

I can't say for sure, but just throught I'd mention it. 





Adam Shprintzen

Adam Shprintzen


Yeah, they are Makura, one of the banners that they are holding going past says so. For some reason the guy with the enormous boom mic walking through the frame near the end cracks me up. The linguistic similarities bit is really interesting...

Helen...perhaps you have some Central Asian ancestry? Bukharan, Uzbek, Tajik, etc...? And not an ancestor with an Asian fetish?





Helen Jupiter

Helen Jupiter


Although no one would ever mistake me for Asian.

Also, the Makura are one of the "Japanese New Religion" groups I was referring to at the end of the article.





Anonymous


Neither, just utter nonsense.

 

"There are no lost tribes." The so called lost tribes of the ancient Kingdom of Israel were conquered by the Assyrians and absorbed into that populations.

Their decendents  are more likely to be found in Damscus and Aleppo than in Kyoto or Tokyo.

 

You will always find accidental similaties of sounds and meanings in any two languages. The key is to find structural features that are the same as you do in Sanskrit and say Latin, or in Hebrew and Akkadian.

 

 





Proud Self-Loather


Um, how could anything in the Torah take place in July?!  The Gregorian calendar came a thousand years after the Torah was written and/or dictated word-for-word from God. There's no date on the Hebrew calendar that matches up with any fixed date on the Gregorian calendar.

Otherwise, you almost had me there...





Anonymous


Do a little research on the religious and cultural traditions of the pathans, particularly the afridis. The resemblances to judaism are more than striking, they are identical.