It seems to me that anyone, and I mean anyone, who sincerely and freely chooses to identify as a Jew, to put his/her lot with one of history most persecuted minorities, deserves our respect and recognition.  These people are reviving an historic stream of Judaism.  Let’s honor,celebrate, and welcome them into the great tent of Judaism.  As Roi hints at the end of his article,you cannot reject them without excluding many other Jews whose identity falls outside the norm.