So what's your point, that we shouldn't talk about what great heroes the Maccabees were?
Yes.
(Like that really comes up during your Hanukkah party.)
I throw Hanukkah parties?
And why is everyone suddenly waking up to the true history of the Hashmoneans now?
It's a sign of the End of Days. Mashiach is coming!
What we teach our kids about heroes has to be different than the full, unadulterated story -- otherwise there would simply be no heroes.
Why would that be a problem?
I'm sorry but by any definition of the word, Judah Maccabee was a true Jewish hero, regardless of what his successors turned into.
Judah Maccabee would have had you beheaded.
More information about formatting options
Eli Valley
Proud Self-Loather
So what's your point, that we shouldn't talk about what great heroes the Maccabees were?
Yes.
(Like that really comes up during your Hanukkah party.)
I throw Hanukkah parties?
And why is everyone suddenly waking up to the true history of the Hashmoneans now?
It's a sign of the End of Days. Mashiach is coming!
What we teach our kids about heroes has to be different than the full, unadulterated story -- otherwise there would simply be no heroes.
Why would that be a problem?
I'm sorry but by any definition of the word, Judah Maccabee was a true Jewish hero, regardless of what his successors turned into.
Judah Maccabee would have had you beheaded.