Arts & Culture
The Beijing Olympics Are Like Berlin in 1936 All Over Again
By Thomas C Laird / April 9, 2008
As the Chinese Communist Party attempts to shove its Olympic Flame down the world’s throat, it is encountering something it finds shocking: Resistance it cannot shoot. Protesters against the Party’s recent massacres in Tibet have hindered the Olympic Flame in London and Paris. Today the “Grab the Torch” game moves to San Francisco. Party hacks are responding to protesters with outrage and hubris. They have branded those who freely express their opinions through protest as “vile.” “No force can stop the torch relay of the Olympic Games,” Sun Weide, spokesman for the Beijing organizing committee, said in Beijing on April 9. Oh, really? No force? Rather confident, are we? No surprise here: The Party does not respect the power of democracy; it does not recognize its legitimacy, thus it does not exist. In fact, citizens of France and England did stop the torch relay in their countries through massive public protests. These protests are expressions of a growing tide of outrage that the Chinese Communist Party was invited to host the 2008 Olympics in the first place. There is a growing sense that if the Beijing Olympics must go forward at all, they should be used to expose the nature of the dictators in Beijing. The major issue for anyone who believes in democracy is simple: This is not about the games, it’s about democracy; the protests are not against the great nation of China, they are against the Chinese Communist Party. Now, in light of recent and continuing massacres in Tibet, the goals and methods of the Party have been exposed yet again.
Why are citizens of democracies allowing the largest mass murderer in human history to wrap itself in the Olympic Flag? You cannot blame the Party. The Party is simply doing what it has always done. It is currently mounting its largest propaganda effort ever. In the past, the Party mounted such campaigns only in China: Let a Hundred Flowers Bloom, The Great Leap Forward, and so on. For those of us outside of China, there are two essential aspects to these campaigns:
- They resulted in the death of at least 30 million Chinese, making the Party the largest mass murderer in history.
- Their primary purpose was to strengthen the Party’s grip on power.
So, what's the Party’s Olympic propaganda campaign all about? The Party wants to convince its own people that it is the legitimate ruler of China. It wants them to forget Tiananmen. It wants to make them ignore what the Party is doing now (and has done for 50 years) in Tibet. It is using propaganda in China to convince Chinese that Tibetan thugs were murdering poor Chinese in Lhasa, and the party had to crack down on them. The Party wants Chinese—and supporters of democracy around the world—to recognize that it is the legitimate ruler of China, even though it has acquired its power by mass murder, and has never been freely supported by those whom it rules.
Modern nations—a status to which China aspires—recognize that legitimacy cannot be conferred by force of arms. The founding principle of modern democracy is that a government acquires legitimacy from the will of the people, as expressed through free elections. There is no substitute for a popular mandate. It is the only currency of political legitimacy. Any régime that acquires and maintains political power through the barrel of a gun—as Chairman Mao so famously expressed it—is ipso facto illegitimate. The sad fact that all athletes preparing to compete in Beijing must recognize is this: When you hold up your medal, you are pinning it onto the chest of the Chinese Communist Party. You are helping the Party convince its own people that it's rule has legitimacy. You are helping the Party hide the facts of history from its own people, and the people of the world. The facts of history are plain to see. The Party executed up to 3 million small landlords in 1953. The rational was simple: You cannot make an omelet without cracking a few eggs. They could not establish communism in China, and they could not create economic equality amongst all classes, until the petty bourgeois were murdered. That was just one of many such propaganda campaigns, which went on for decades. At least 30 million (and perhaps as many as 70 million) people died to establish the ideals of communism in China. How has that worked out? Well, today the Communist Party has dropped Communism as a realistic ideal. State-managed capitalism and crony capitalism are now the driving engine of China’s march to super-power status. The Party serves as the slave master for foreign corporations: Our shoes are cheap in America because the Party forces Chinese to work without free unions.
Hosting the Olympics is the Chinese Communist Party’s conscious attempt to confer legitimacy to its rule, methods, and goals. It seeks legitimacy in China and around the world. Sound familiar? The Nazi Party tried this in 1936. Western athletes who claim we must not taint the Olympics with politics are speaking from ignorance or self-interest. Is that what they would have said to homosexuals and Gypsies who were already being rounded up by the Nazis, even as the world gathered to celebrate the 1936 Olympics in Berlin? Is that what they would have said to German Jews, in 1936, who though not yet being arrested, were already forbidden to enter stores or restaurants? Just what part of “Never Again” do those in Europe and America, who accept the Party’s Olympic propaganda campaign, not understand? Samantha Power has quoted author David Rieff's suggestion that, "'Never again' might best be defined as 'Never again will Germans kill Jews in Europe in the 1940's.'” I suggest that “never again” means we cannot allow the Party—already guilty of mass murder in Tibet and China—to host the Olympics even as it supports genocide in Sudan and Burma. That’s the Party that is just dying to meet you in Beijing: A Party that is even now massacring Tibetans, once again, while our governments do nothing. The Party is doing the same thing it has been doing for the last 50 years, and with the Olympics on the horizon, the situation bears an increasingly eerie resemblance to Berlin in 1936. Time to stand up and be counted. What You Can Do Start A Conversation: When you buy a pair of shoes, explain to the clerk that you need them to help you find a pair that were not made in China. They will ask why, and you can explain that the Chinese shoes are cheap because the Chinese Communist Party:
- Prevents its laborers from forming unions
- Does not enforce China’s EPA regulations (which American manufacturers are required to do)
This education process can work in any store. Educate yourself about why Chinese goods are so cheap. When you go to Whole Foods, and cannot find frozen edamame except from China, ask to see the Manager. Explain to them why you will not buy the edamame from China, and ask why Whole Foods is not supporting American farmers.
Whenever you have time, every purchase, in every store, can be a moment to spread the facts about the Party. The real strength of a democracy is educated citizens. Protest: If you're in San Francisco, you can protest against the Olympic Torch.
Get involved with Students for a Free Tibet and join in some of their actions.
Educate Yourself: Thomas Laird worked with the Dalai Lama over the past ten years to write a popular history of Tibet. The Story of Tibet: Conversations with The Dalai Lama is the first-ever history of Tibet written with a Dalai Lama. This is required reading if you want to know what’s happening in Tibet and China during this Olympic year. You can read reviews of the book and a sample chapter here.
Laird contributed interviews to this interesting Australian radio piece on Chinese and Tibetan History.
You can also hear him n the Paula Gordon show, and on WHYY, Philly.
Watch this chilling, detailed, covertly-made documentary about what the Party is doing in Tibet.
One of the most amazing video reports about the recent protests in Tibet is here.
China Tibet War on Youtube: See The Party version of history and recent events here. Watch a rebuttal here.
Keep abreast of Tibetan news here.
Here is a story to start with: The Party thugs who are providing security to the running of the Olympic Flame through the streets of San Francisco were selected from a special unit of the People’s Liberation Army. This same unit is used to suppress Tibetans in Tibet. Imagine that Nazi Party Brown Shirts were running an Olympic Flame through a US City in 1936. That’s what’s happening as we sit and watch. See the facts, here.
Ask yourself: Who made the decision that it was okay for these thugs be on the ground in a US city? Find out, and protest directly to them. What message does that send to the Party? That their actions in Tibet are legitimate?
Links to Follow:
Tibet Justice Center Students for a Free Tibet International Campaign for Tibet International Tibet Support Network Tibetan Centre for Human Rights and Democracy Human Rights in China



POST A COMMENT
Thomas C. Laird,
Parenti lists his references, besides did you read the article? He writes,
"Whether
Chinese rule has brought betterment or disaster is not the central
issue here. The question is what kind of country was old Tibet. What I
am disputing is the supposedly pristine spiritual nature of that
pre-invasion culture. We can advocate religious freedom and independence for a new Tibet without having to embrace the mythology about old Tibet. Tibetan
feudalism was cloaked in Buddhism, but the two are not to be equated.
In reality, old Tibet was not a Paradise Lost. It was a retrograde
repressive theocracy of extreme privilege and poverty, a long way from
Shangri-La."
Besides he is not the only source I gave, did you see the National Geographic Video I linked above? Here is another source. Note: while Parenti does not blame Buddhism for the feudalism of TIbet,
the person in this video says Buddhism, which was introduced from
India, is what brought about a caste system in Tibet http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xsoc4-QnplY
By the way, the UN courts ruled that Serbian soldiers did not commit genocide. See
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/1530781.stm
Don't you see how this double standard affects our relationship with weaker/poorer countries?Â
You may disagree with this decision, but guess what, the United States is responsible for more deaths in Iraq, than the number of deaths attributed to Serbians. Yet how many high level Americans government officials have been put on trial for their war crimes?
Hey Randall. This room is empty. Its just you and me now. All others have long ago abandoned the fray. So are you ready to learn something, or are you just going to defend without listening?
Think about what you just wrote. "I don't know much about this situation". Very good. First step. You don't know much about the former Yugoslovia. Well guess what, the entire educated world agrees that history proves, beyond any shadow of a doubt that Milosevic ordered Genocide. So ask yourself, why is Parenti defending the genocidal ruler of Serbia? And doesn't it strike you as funny that Parenti is also defending the mass murderers who rule China and Tibet?
Think. I spent more than30 years of my life in Asia; years in Tibet. And you don't even know if Parenti has ever even been to Tibet but you are going to take his word over mine about Tibet?
Why? Why is it so important to you that Parenti's false description of Tibetan society is 'true'? If Parenti is willing to lie about genocide in Yugoslovia… might he not be willing to do the same thing in Tibet?
Think. We can all change, learn, grow…. you don't have to stick to reflexive positions
Collective punishment" is a term used often used to describe Israel's retaliation against Hamas terrorist attacks. Teheran usually rushes to be the first in line to accuse the Jewish state. Yet the Iranian regime's claim to represent the interests of Arabs is belied by its brutal persecution of the indigenous Ahwazi Arabs living within its own territory, who have been under direct rule from Persians since the end of self-government in 1925. This week, Iran cut off drinking water supply to Arab villages along the left bank of the Shatt al-Arab, causing social unrest and fears of an outbreak of disease.
Ahwazi Arabs are the most deprived and persecuted ethnic group in the Middle East, with human development indicators at an African level – far below those of the Palestinians. This ethno-national group has been subjected to forced relocation, land confiscation, cultural repression, state terrorism, mass executions and economic disadvantage, even though their land is one of the most oil-rich regions in the world. Being deprived of drinking water is simply the latest atrocity committed against them.
Although the area has many large rivers – the Karoon and the Karkeh as well as the Shatt al-Arab – water has become salinated by intensive sugar cane production and polluted by the petrochemical industries. It is now undrinkable, particularly at the mouth of the Karoon where the river feeds into the Shatt al-Arab. In the late 1990s, riots broke out in the oil town of Abadan, which lies on the Shatt Al-Arab, over the lack of clean drinking water. Security forces killed dozens of Ahwazi Arabs during these "water riots."
The government eventually responded to the problem by supplying drinking water in tanks to villages and towns in the affected areas. The halt in drinking water supply is likely to lead to outbreaks of water-born diseases such as cholera and typhoid – this in a region which has more oil than Kuwait and the UAE combined. It will also incite yet more Ahwazi Arab unrest.
The intention behind the action is two-fold: to punish and intimidate the restive Arab population and to drive them off their traditional lands so as to strengthen the regime's military presence in the region and bolster the economic interests of a predatory religious elite.
Ahwazi Arabs are being punished for armed attacks on bus convoys operated by the Rahiyan-e-Nur, a section of the hard-line volunteer paramilitary force the Bassij which is responsible for visits to the Iran-Iraq War battlefields. The Bassij are hated by the Ahwazi Arabs, largely because the Bassijis are deployed to murder any Arab opponents of the regime.
Forced relocation is also thought to be part of a long-term plan to force indigenous Arabs from their villages to expand the Arvand Free Zone, a military-industrial complex being developed along the Shatt al-Arab. Arabs living on Minoo Island, south of Abadan, have already faced state intimidation and expulsion. Most Ahwazi Arabs believe this is in line with the government's ethnic cleansing program, which was outlined in a letter written by then vice-president Ali Abtahi and leaked to the press in April 2005.
ULTIMATELY, CONTROL over the Shatt al-Arab – achieved by settling a loyal non-indigenous population on traditional Arab land – will give Iran a stranglehold over Baghdad and thereby the entire Middle East. The ethnic cleansing of Ahwazi Arabs is nothing less than a prelude to the extension of Iran's empire and a projection of the principle of Velayat-e-Faqih, rule by Shi'ite religious jurisprudence headed by Iran's supreme leader. The presence of a large, dispossessed and restless Arab population along the border is simply the last hurdle for Iran's plan to expand its sphere of influence. What better tactic than to drive them out with disease and starvation?
The plight of Ahwazi Arabs is crucial to security in the Middle East. Yet Ahwazi Arabs can neither rely on their Iranian religious compatriots nor their Arab ethnic brothers for support. Iranian "opposition" movements have often indicated that they would stand alongside the current regime against Ahwazi Arabs to prevent what they see as the destruction of their country by an "alien" race – even though Ahwazis themselves do not advocate secession.
Ahwazi Arabs also have few friends in the Arab world. As they are predominantly Shi'ite, Ahwazis elicit little sympathy from their Sunni Arab brothers. Moreover, many governments in the region are careful not to upset the militaristic and aggressive power lying to their north. They view the Ahwazi issue as a struggle that could cause them unnecessary problems were they to be involved.
If the Iranian regime is to be prevented from driving the Ahwazi Arabs literally off the map, then it's vital that their predicament be placed firmly on the "political map" in the West as well as the Arab world. International solidarity is essential to ending Ahwazi Arabs' persecution and to secure regional political stability.
Wanna post your own comments? Gotta log in first!